Decoded

The End of the Common School

Decoded analysis cover: The End of the Common School
Anthropology of Contemporary America | Article 7 of 10

Abstract

In 2022 Arizona became the first state to make every schoolchild eligible for an education savings account (ESA), a public deposit that families can spend on private tuition, tutoring, therapies, curricula and other approved services. By the 2026-27 school year, at least seventeen states were scheduled to run universal private school choice programmes, and about half of American schoolchildren were eligible for public funds to pay for education outside the public school system. The number of students in private school choice programmes more than doubled in four years, to around 1.5 million. In Texas, the new Education Freedom Accounts programme received more than 274,000 applications for fewer than 100,000 places in its first year. Alongside these programmes, a new sector of “microschools”, small schools often of fewer than twenty or thirty pupils, meeting in homes, churches and commercial spaces, has grown to an estimated one to one and a half million students. Debate about these changes is intense and familiar: supporters speak of freedom, innovation and parental rights; critics of the defunding of public schools, accountability and inequality.

This article sets that debate aside to ask an anthropological question: what happens to a society’s rituals of belonging, its forms of exchange and its relation between household and state when the common school ceases to be common? Drawing on Émile Durkheim on moral education, Benedict Anderson on imagined communities, Paul Bohannan on spheres of exchange, Viviana Zelizer on earmarked money and the “priceless child”, Annette Lareau on concerted cultivation and James Scott on state legibility, it makes five claims. First, the shift marks a passage from territorial to elective educational community, ending the public school’s role as a shared civic ritual. Second, ESAs create a new sphere of exchange, with its own special-purpose money and its own moral boundaries. Third, schooling is returning to the household and the congregation, reversing a century and a half in which the state moved education out of both. Fourth, choice expresses and intensifies the culture of the bespoke child, turning education into a project of personal fit and making the labour of choosing a new form of parental work. Fifth, the new sector produces illegible schools, accountable to parents rather than to the public, whose number, content and results the state can no longer fully see.

Keywords: education, ritual, community, exchange, money, household, state, United States

1. Introduction: a school of twenty

The school occupies the ground floor of a converted office building in a suburban strip. There are three rooms: one for the youngest children, one for the older ones and one, with beanbags and bookshelves, for reading and quiet work. Eighteen pupils, aged six to thirteen, are enrolled. Two “guides”, one with a teaching licence and one without, lead the day. There is no bell. The children work on projects, some individually, some in small groups, and spend part of each morning on online mathematics and reading programmes that track their progress. On Fridays they visit a nature preserve or a local business. Most of the families pay with funds from the state’s education savings account; a few pay tuition themselves. Several of the children have diagnoses, of attention deficit, dyslexia or autism, that made their previous schools difficult. The parents chose this school, one mother explains, because “it fits him”.

Scenes like this have multiplied across the United States since the pandemic. The National Microschooling Center, an organisation that supports the sector, estimated in 2026 that some 1.5 million students attended microschools, while acknowledging that other estimates are closer to a million and that nobody truly knows. Its surveys describe a sector of small schools: the median private microschool had about twenty students; most served primary-age children; nearly two in five operated in commercial premises, more than one in five in houses of worship and about one in six in private homes. Most relied mainly on tuition, though a growing share received state choice funds. Two-thirds were not accredited, though most wanted to be. Founders listed growth in “non-academic learning” as their most important goal for students.

The expansion of state funding is the driving force behind this growth. Education savings accounts, pioneered in Arizona in 2011 for students with disabilities and made universal there in 2022, became within a few years the preferred instrument of school choice legislation. West Virginia, Iowa, Utah, Arkansas, Florida, Oklahoma, Alabama, Tennessee, Texas and others adopted universal or near-universal programmes. Arizona’s programme grew from about 12,000 students in 2022 to more than 100,000 by 2025, at a cost of nearly 900 million dollars. Florida’s ESA programmes served more than half a million students. Texas launched its 1-billion-dollar Education Freedom Accounts in 2026, providing about 10,474 dollars per student, with roughly 70 percent of awarded students expected to attend private schools and 30 percent to homeschool or use other options. Federal legislation enacted in 2025 created a national tax-credit scholarship to begin in 2027, in states that opt in.

The debate over these programmes is among the most polarised in American education. Supporters argue that they give families, especially those of modest means, the freedom to choose schools that fit their children, as wealthy families have always done; that they break the monopoly of district schools; that they encourage innovation; and that they respect the rights of parents. Critics argue that they divert public money from public schools, subsidise families who were already in private schools, lack accountability for results, permit discrimination by private providers, and threaten the civic mission of public education. Empirical research on effects is mixed and contested, and the sector is too new for long-term evidence.

This article takes no side in this debate. Its purpose is to analyse the transformation from an anthropological perspective: to ask what the common school meant as a social institution, and what the turn to choice does to the forms of community, exchange and authority that the school embodied. Section 2 examines the end of the common school as a territorial civic ritual. Section 3 analyses ESAs as a new sphere of exchange. Section 4 turns to the return of schooling to the household and the congregation. Section 5 examines the bespoke child. Section 6 considers the illegible school. Section 7 concludes.

2. From territorial to elective community

2.1 The school as a secular church

Émile Durkheim, who held the first chair of education and sociology at the Sorbonne, saw the school as the central institution of moral life in modern societies. In a society that had lost the unifying force of religion, he argued, the public school had to take over the church’s role in forming citizens: instilling discipline, attachment to social groups and autonomy of the will. The school was, in effect, a secular church, in which children were initiated into the moral community of the nation. Its rituals, its calendar, its common curriculum and its shared spaces produced the sense of belonging on which social solidarity rested.

The American common school, as conceived by Horace Mann and the reformers of the 1830s and 1840s, rested on a similar vision. Mann called the common school “the great equalizer of the conditions of men” and saw it as the means of forming a unified republican citizenry out of a diverse and growing population. The school would bring together the children of rich and poor, native and immigrant, in a shared institution that taught a common civic morality. Over the following century, the public school became one of the central institutions of American life, and its rituals became national rituals: the Pledge of Allegiance recited each morning, the flag in every classroom, the assemblies, the school spirit, the football games, the proms, the graduation ceremonies with their caps and gowns.

2.2 The territorial principle

The American public school was not only a civic institution; it was a territorial one. Children attended the school assigned to them by their address. The school district was a unit of local government with its own taxes, board and identity. In many communities, especially in small towns and suburbs, the school was the principal public institution, the place where residents met, the focus of local pride and the measure of a community’s quality. The high school football team carried the town’s name; its games were among the community’s rituals.

Benedict Anderson argued that nations are “imagined communities”, in which people who will never meet imagine themselves as members of a common body, through shared media, calendars and institutions. The territorial public school was one of the principal means by which American local communities, and through them the nation, were imagined. Children of a given place shared a school, a calendar and a set of experiences; they belonged to a cohort defined by place and year. “Class of 1985, Central High” was an identity that lasted a lifetime.

This territorial principle was never perfect. Residential segregation by race and income meant that school districts reproduced the inequalities of housing markets; wealthier families bought access to better schools by buying houses in better districts. Private and parochial schools have always existed alongside the public system, enrolling about a tenth of American students. The common school was, in practice, less common than its ideal. But the ideal was powerful, and the territorial organisation of public education gave it material form.

2.3 Communities of affinity

The expansion of choice replaces the territorial principle with an elective one. Families choose a school, or an assemblage of educational services, on the basis of their values, their child’s needs and their preferences, regardless of where they live. The resulting educational communities are communities of affinity: families who share a pedagogical philosophy, a religious tradition, a concern for a particular kind of learner or simply a dissatisfaction with what the district school offered.

The German sociologist Ferdinand Tönnies distinguished between Gemeinschaft, community based on shared place, kinship and tradition, and Gesellschaft, association based on choice and interest. The elective school community is a curious hybrid. It is chosen, like a Gesellschaft, but it often aspires to the intimacy of a Gemeinschaft: the microschool founders who speak of their school as a “family”, the parent co-operatives, the small congregational schools. It is a community of the like-minded rather than of the co-located.

The consequences for civic ritual are significant. In an elective system, the shared rituals of the territorial school, the common calendar, the community football game, the cohort identity, are fragmented. Each school community has its own rituals, often meaningful and intense, but they are not shared with the wider locality. The child of a microschool in a strip mall does not belong to “Central High”; she belongs to a community of eighteen families chosen for their affinity. The imagined community that the territorial school produced is replaced by many smaller imagined communities, each defined by values rather than place.

Supporters of choice argue that this is a gain: that communities of shared values are stronger and more supportive than communities of mere proximity, and that families should not be forced into institutions that conflict with their beliefs. Critics argue that it is a loss: that a democracy needs institutions in which people who disagree are brought together, and that elective communities, by sorting families by values, will deepen the divisions already visible in American politics. The anthropological perspective suggests that both are right about different things. Elective communities can produce intense belonging; territorial communities produce extensive belonging. The question is whether a society can maintain enough of the second while expanding the first.

2.4 The rituals of the small school

Elective communities do not lack rituals; they invent their own. Observers of microschools describe a ritual life quite different from that of the large public school. Days often begin with a “morning circle” in which children and adults sit together, share news and set intentions, a practice borrowed from Montessori and progressive traditions. Learning is marked not by report cards but by “exhibitions” or “portfolio nights”, in which children present their projects to parents and peers. End-of-year ceremonies may involve a handful of graduates, each of whom is individually celebrated, often with speeches by teachers who have known them for years.

These rituals are intimate rather than collective. They resemble family celebrations more than civic ceremonies. Where the public high school graduation honours a cohort of hundreds, processing in identical gowns to receive identical diplomas, the microschool ceremony honours individuals, each with a distinctive story. The ritual expresses the elective community’s values: personalisation, relationship, recognition of the individual.

Homeschooling communities have developed their own versions of the rituals they left behind. Homeschool co-operatives organise proms, sports leagues, science fairs, yearbooks and graduation ceremonies, recreating the civic rituals of the public school within the elective community. These recreations are revealing. They show that families who leave the territorial school do not reject its rituals; they want them, but on their own terms, within a community they have chosen. The rituals of American adolescence, the prom, the varsity game, the cap and gown, survive the end of the common school, but they are detached from the territorial community and reattached to communities of affinity.

The anthropological significance lies in the scale and the reference of the rituals. The territorial school’s rituals referred to a place, the town, and through it to the nation; their participants were bound by co-residence. The elective school’s rituals refer to a chosen community and to the individual child; their participants are bound by shared values. Both produce belonging, but of different kinds. The question for American civic life is whether the many small belongings can add up to a shared one.

This is the first claim of this article: the expansion of school choice marks a passage from territorial to elective educational community, replacing a system in which children belonged to the school of their place with one in which families choose communities of affinity. This weakens the public school’s historical role as a shared civic ritual, in Durkheim’s sense, and fragments one of the institutions through which American local and national communities were imagined.

3. A new sphere of exchange

3.1 Special-purpose money

In the 1950s the anthropologist Paul Bohannan described the economy of the Tiv of central Nigeria as organised into separate “spheres of exchange”. Subsistence goods, such as food and household items, circulated in one sphere. Prestige goods, such as cattle, slaves, brass rods and a particular kind of white cloth, circulated in another. Rights in people, especially in women through marriage, formed a third and highest sphere. Exchanges within a sphere were normal; exchanges between spheres were morally charged. Converting subsistence goods into prestige goods was admirable; converting prestige goods into subsistence goods was shameful. Brass rods functioned as a special-purpose money, valid only within the prestige sphere. When colonial rule introduced general-purpose money, which could buy anything, it eroded the boundaries between spheres and disrupted the moral order they sustained.

Modern economies are usually thought to be unified by general-purpose money. But Viviana Zelizer showed that, in practice, people constantly “earmark” money, distinguishing funds by source and purpose: wages and gifts, allowances and savings, “pin money” and household money. Governments also create special-purpose monies: food stamps, which can buy only food; housing vouchers, which can pay only rent; health savings accounts, which can pay only medical expenses. Each creates a bounded sphere of exchange, with rules about what may and may not be bought.

3.2 The education dollar

Education savings accounts create such a sphere. The funds deposited in an ESA are money, but a special kind of money. They can be spent only on approved educational goods and services: private school tuition, tutoring, textbooks, curricula, educational therapies, online courses, testing fees, sometimes uniforms, transportation or technology. They cannot be withdrawn as cash, spent on food or rent, or transferred to another family. Unspent funds may roll over to the following year, as in Texas, but remain within the sphere. The accounts are administered through digital platforms operated by private contractors, which maintain catalogues of approved vendors and products, process payments and review purchases.

The result is a new marketplace with its own currency. Families become purchasers, assembling their children’s education from a menu of goods and services. Providers, from established private schools to individual tutors, microschool founders and online curriculum companies, become vendors, competing for the education dollar. Advocates call this “unbundling”: the decomposition of the school, once a single package provided by the state, into components that families can buy separately. Platforms market their catalogues to parents, and a new industry of consultants and advisers has appeared to help families navigate them.

3.3 The boundary of the sphere

As Bohannan’s analysis would predict, the boundaries of this new sphere have become the site of intense moral controversy. What counts as education? In Arizona and other states, news reports and audits have publicised ESA purchases that critics deemed inappropriate: musical instruments, sports and outdoor equipment, ski passes, amusement-park tickets. Supporters responded that such items could have legitimate educational uses, that families are better judges of their children’s needs than bureaucrats, and that public schools also spend on music, sports and field trips. Regulators have tightened and loosened rules; lists of approved and prohibited items have been revised repeatedly.

These disputes are not merely administrative. They are disputes about the definition of the sphere, and therefore about the definition of education itself. When education was provided by the public school, its content was defined by the institution: whatever the school did was education. When education is purchased by families from vendors, its content must be defined item by item, and every purchase raises the question of whether it belongs inside the sphere. A piano lesson is education; is a piano? A trip to a science museum is education; is a trip to a theme park with a science exhibit? The anxiety about “leakage” from the education sphere into the consumption sphere is the same anxiety that Bohannan observed among the Tiv when brass rods were used to buy food: a fear that a morally elevated domain is being contaminated by ordinary consumption.

The special-purpose money also changes the relationship between family and state. In the public school system, the state provided education directly; the family received it. In the ESA system, the state provides money; the family spends it. The family becomes an administrator of public funds, accountable for their proper use, subject to audit and review. This is a new role, which some families embrace as empowerment and others experience as a burden. It transforms the parent from a recipient of public services into a manager of a public account.

This is the second claim of this article: education savings accounts create a new sphere of exchange, with a special-purpose money that circulates only among approved educational goods and services. Like the spheres that Bohannan described among the Tiv, this sphere has moral boundaries, and the controversies over what may be purchased are disputes about the definition of education itself. The family, in this system, becomes both a purchaser in a marketplace and an administrator of public funds.

4. The return to the household and the congregation

4.1 How the state took schooling

For most of human history, children were educated in the household and the community: by parents, relatives, masters, priests and neighbours. Formal schooling, where it existed, was usually connected to religious institutions. The rise of mass public schooling in the nineteenth century, in Europe and the United States, was a historic transfer of education from the household and the church to the state. In the United States, this transfer was contested. The common school movement was in part a Protestant project, and the conflicts over Bible reading in public schools in the nineteenth century led many Catholic communities to build their own parochial school system. Over time, public schools became increasingly secular, and the Supreme Court’s decisions of the 1960s ending organised prayer and devotional Bible reading in public schools completed the separation.

By the late twentieth century, the dominant American model placed education in a specialised public institution, distinct from both household and congregation, staffed by credentialed professionals and governed by public authorities. Homeschooling, which had almost disappeared, was revived from the 1970s onwards by a coalition of religious conservatives and progressive “unschoolers”, and gained legal recognition in all states by the early 1990s. But it remained a marginal practice until the pandemic.

4.2 The household school

The pandemic of 2020 forced nearly all American children into a form of household schooling, as schools closed and lessons moved online. Many families discovered that they preferred some version of education at home, or in small groups, and did not return to the district school when it reopened. Homeschooling rates rose sharply and, according to several analyses, have remained well above their pre-pandemic level. Microschools, “learning pods” and hybrid models combining home and group instruction emerged from this experience.

The new sector represents, in part, a return of education to the household. Homeschooling families teach their own children, often with the help of online curricula, co-operatives and tutors. Many microschools operate in private homes. Parents, especially mothers, found and run many of them. The boundary between household and school, which mass public schooling established, has become porous. In Texas, about a third of the first cohort of ESA recipients chose homeschooling or alternatives to private school, carrying public funds into the household.

4.3 The congregational school

The new sector also represents, in part, a return of education to the congregation. More than one microschool in five, according to the National Microschooling Center, operates in a house of worship. Many private schools that accept ESA funds are religious, and ESA programmes have provided new revenue for Christian, Jewish and Muslim schools. The Supreme Court’s decisions in Espinoza v. Montana Department of Revenue (2020) and Carson v. Makin (2022) held that states that fund private education may not exclude religious schools on the basis of their religious character or activity, clearing the constitutional path for public money to flow to religious education. The church basement and the synagogue classroom are again places where children are schooled, now with public support.

In Durkheimian terms, this is a striking reversal. Durkheim saw the transfer of moral education from the church to the secular school as a necessary step in the evolution of modern societies. The American return of schooling to the congregation, financed by public funds, partially undoes this transfer. Supporters see it as a restoration of religious liberty and of parents’ right to educate their children in their faith. Critics see it as an erosion of the secular public sphere. Anthropologically, it is a reconfiguration of the relationship between the three institutions, household, congregation and state, that have competed for the education of children throughout modern history.

4.4 The teacher without the institution

The return of schooling to the household and the congregation also changes the figure of the teacher. In the public system, the teacher is a credentialed professional, licensed by the state, employed by a district, often represented by a union and embedded in a bureaucratic hierarchy. The sociologist Andrew Abbott showed that professions are defined by their jurisdiction over a domain of work, which they defend against competitors; teaching’s jurisdiction over the classroom was secured by licensing requirements and the near-monopoly of public employment.

The new sector loosens this jurisdiction. Many microschools employ “guides” or “facilitators” rather than teachers, some licensed and some not. Founders are often former public school teachers who left the system in search of autonomy, and who describe their new role in entrepreneurial terms: they are building their own schools, setting their own curricula, recruiting their own families. Others are parents with no teaching background. Homeschooling parents teach their own children. Online platforms supply instruction in some subjects, and the human adult in the room acts as a coach or mentor rather than a lecturer.

This produces two contradictory movements. On the one hand, a deprofessionalisation: the boundary between the licensed teacher and the unlicensed adult blurs, and the authority of the credential weakens. On the other hand, a reprofessionalisation on new terms: the microschool founder who combines teaching, administration and entrepreneurship, and who is accountable to families rather than to a district, embodies a different model of the educational professional, closer to the independent physician or the craftsman than to the civil servant. Which of these movements prevails will shape the future status of teaching in American society.

The figure of the teacher-founder also has a pre-modern echo. Before mass public schooling, many schools were the personal enterprises of individual teachers, who gathered pupils, charged fees and taught in their homes or rented rooms: the dame schools of colonial New England, the academies of the early republic, the tutors of wealthy families. The microschool founder revives this figure, with the difference that public money, through ESAs, now pays the fees.

This is the third claim of this article: the new educational sector marks a return of schooling to the household and the congregation, reversing in part the historic transfer of education from both to the secular state. Home-based microschools and homeschooling bring education back into the domestic sphere, while religious schools and congregational microschools, now eligible for public funds, bring it back into the religious sphere.

5. The bespoke child

5.1 “It fits him”

When parents explain why they chose a microschool, a homeschool arrangement or a private school funded by an ESA, the language of fit recurs. The school “fits” the child; the previous school “didn’t work for her”; the family was looking for something that “meets him where he is”. The National Microschooling Center’s surveys found that small classes, individualised attention and a safe environment were the top reasons parents gave. The sector attracts a high concentration of children with learning differences, attention deficits, anxiety and autism; in one 2026 study of microschool students, nearly half had special learning needs and more than a quarter had mental health needs. Observers have also noted the appeal of microschools for boys, who on average fare worse than girls in conventional classrooms.

The language of fit expresses a conception of the child as a unique individual whose education should be tailored, like a bespoke garment, to his or her particular needs, temperament and talents. This conception is not new; it runs through progressive education from Rousseau to Dewey and Montessori. But the new sector gives it institutional form and public funding. The ESA, which allows families to assemble an education from separate components, is the instrument of the bespoke child: the account follows the child, not the school, and is spent on what this particular child needs.

5.2 The priceless child

Viviana Zelizer, in Pricing the Priceless Child (1985), traced the transformation of the American child between the 1870s and the 1930s from an economically useful member of the household, whose labour contributed to family income, to an economically “useless” but emotionally “priceless” being, valued for love and sentiment. This “sacralisation” of the child, Zelizer showed, was accompanied by the removal of children from work and their placement in school, and by new forms of investment in children’s emotional and educational development.

The bespoke child is the latest stage of this sacralisation. The priceless child deserved protection and love; the bespoke child deserves an education designed for him or her alone. The standardised education of the common school, with its age-graded classrooms, uniform curriculum and batch processing of pupils, was compatible with the priceless child, who was valued but not necessarily individualised. It sits uneasily with the bespoke child, whose uniqueness demands an education as unique as the child.

5.3 Concerted cultivation and the labour of choosing

The sociologist Annette Lareau, in Unequal Childhoods (2003), distinguished two styles of American parenting. Middle-class parents practised “concerted cultivation”: the deliberate development of children’s talents through organised activities, negotiation with institutions and intensive parental involvement. Working-class and poor parents practised the “accomplishment of natural growth”: providing care and allowing children to develop with less structured intervention. Lareau showed that concerted cultivation gave middle-class children advantages in dealing with schools and other institutions.

School choice extends concerted cultivation into the choice of schooling itself. In the territorial system, most families accepted the assigned school; the work of choosing was done, if at all, by choosing a place to live. In the elective system, every family must choose, and the choice is an ongoing project: researching options, visiting schools, comparing curricula, applying for accounts, managing purchases, monitoring the child’s progress, switching if the fit is wrong. This is substantial labour, and, like the kin work discussed earlier in this series, it falls disproportionately on mothers. It also requires resources: time, information, digital literacy and social networks.

Supporters of choice argue that public funding democratises concerted cultivation, giving families of modest means the options that wealthy families have always had. The data on microschool families, most of whom earn at or above the average income, and on early ESA recipients, many of whom were already in private schools or homeschooling, suggest that, at least initially, the families most able to perform the labour of choosing benefit most. The new sector may thus extend opportunity and reproduce inequality at the same time, depending on whether the labour of choosing can be supported for those who lack the resources to perform it.

This is the fourth claim of this article: school choice expresses and intensifies the culture of the bespoke child, the latest stage in the sacralisation of the American child that Zelizer described. It makes the tailoring of education to the individual child a public entitlement, and it turns the choosing of schools into a new form of parental labour, an extension of the concerted cultivation that Lareau identified as a middle-class practice.

6. The illegible school

6.1 Seeing like a state

James Scott, in Seeing Like a State (1998), argued that modern states depend on making their societies legible: simplified, standardised and measurable, so that they can be counted, taxed, planned and governed. Standard surnames, cadastral maps, uniform measures and censuses were instruments of legibility. Scott showed that legibility brought real benefits but also imposed simplifications that ignored local knowledge and complexity.

The public school system is one of the great instruments of state legibility. It enrols children in known institutions, assigns them to grades, tests them on standardised measures, reports results by school and district, and certifies their progress with diplomas. Through it, the state knows how many children are being educated, where, in what, and with what results. The accountability movement of the 1990s and 2000s, culminating in the No Child Left Behind Act of 2002, intensified this legibility by requiring annual testing and public reporting.

6.2 What the state cannot see

The new sector is much less legible. There is no reliable count of microschools: the National Microschooling Center’s estimates rest on surveys of its own networks, and its chief executive acknowledged that there was no reliable count even for Texas. Homeschooling registration requirements vary widely; some states require none. Microschools may operate as private schools, homeschool co-operatives, learning centres or childcare businesses, depending on state law, and many fall into gaps between categories. Most are not accredited. Their assessment practices, according to the Center’s surveys, rely mainly on observation-based reporting, portfolios and assessments embedded in digital tools, rather than state tests. Many ESA programmes require some form of testing, but often allow families to choose among national norm-referenced tests, and results are reported in aggregate if at all. Researchers at the RAND Corporation described measuring the academic effects of microschools as nearly impossible with existing data.

From the perspective of the state, this is a loss of sight. Public authorities can no longer fully know how many children are being educated, where, in what and with what results. From the perspective of many families and providers, it is a liberation from a narrow and bureaucratic conception of education. The microschool founders who list “non-academic learning” as their primary goal are rejecting the simplification that standardised testing imposes, in favour of the complex, local and personal knowledge of the child that Scott’s analysis would recognise.

6.3 From public to personal accountability

The change is, at bottom, a change in the form of accountability. The public school is accountable to the public, through elected boards, state standards and published results. The microschool is accountable to parents, who can see their children daily, know the teachers personally, and leave if they are dissatisfied. Max Weber distinguished between legal-rational authority, based on rules and procedures, and traditional or personal authority, based on relationships and trust. The shift from public to personal accountability is a shift from the former towards the latter.

Personal accountability has strengths: it is immediate, responsive and grounded in direct knowledge. It also has weaknesses: it depends on parents’ ability to judge, it offers little protection to children whose parents do not or cannot exercise it, and it provides the public, which pays, with little information about what it is paying for. As public funding of the sector grows into the billions, the tension between personal and public accountability is likely to sharpen. Legislatures will be pressed to require more reporting; providers and families will resist. The outcome will determine whether the new sector remains illegible or is gradually drawn back into the state’s field of vision.

This is the fifth claim of this article: the new sector produces illegible schools, in James Scott’s sense: schools that the state cannot fully count, categorise or measure, accountable to parents rather than to the public. This represents both a liberation from bureaucratic simplification and a loss of public knowledge, and the tension between personal and public accountability will define the sector’s future.

7. Conclusion: the end of the common school?

The common school was never as common as its ideal. It was shaped by residential segregation, contested by religious minorities, and challenged by private alternatives from the beginning. But it was, for a century and a half, one of the central institutions through which American society imagined and reproduced itself: a territorial, secular, legible institution that brought the children of a place together in a shared civic ritual.

The expansion of education savings accounts and the rise of microschools transform each of these features. The territorial community gives way to the elective community of affinity. A new sphere of exchange, with its own special-purpose money, replaces direct public provision. The household and the congregation recover part of the educational role the state took from them. The bespoke child replaces the standardised pupil. And the illegible school, accountable to parents, escapes the measurement that the public system imposed.

These changes are not necessarily the end of public education, which still enrols the large majority of American children. But they mark the end of its monopoly on the public imagination of what schooling is. American society is experimenting, on a large scale and with substantial public funding, with a different model of education, closer in some respects to the pre-modern model of household and congregational learning, and in others to the modern consumer marketplace.

Whether this experiment strengthens or weakens American society will depend on questions that this article cannot answer: whether elective communities can coexist with shared civic institutions; whether the special-purpose money of ESAs reaches those who most need it; whether the household and congregational schools teach the habits of democratic citizenship; whether the bespoke child becomes a fulfilled adult; and whether the public can find ways to know what its money buys without destroying what families value. The answers will shape not only American education but the forms of community and belonging through which the next generation of Americans will imagine their country.

References

Abbott, Andrew. 1988. The System of Professions: An Essay on the Division of Expert Labor. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.

Anderson, Benedict. 1983. Imagined Communities: Reflections on the Origin and Spread of Nationalism. London: Verso.

Bohannan, Paul. 1959. “The Impact of Money on an African Subsistence Economy.” Journal of Economic History 19 (4): 491-503.

Durkheim, Émile. 1961 [1925]. Moral Education: A Study in the Theory and Application of the Sociology of Education. New York: Free Press.

EdChoice. 2026. The ABCs of School Choice, 2026 Edition. Indianapolis: EdChoice.

Lareau, Annette. 2003. Unequal Childhoods: Class, Race, and Family Life. Berkeley: University of California Press.

National Microschooling Center. 2026. American Microschools: Sector Analysis 2026. Washington, DC: National Microschooling Center.

Scott, James C. 1998. Seeing Like a State: How Certain Schemes to Improve the Human Condition Have Failed. New Haven: Yale University Press.

Tönnies, Ferdinand. 2001 [1887]. Community and Civil Society. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Weber, Max. 1978 [1922]. Economy and Society. Berkeley: University of California Press.

Zelizer, Viviana A. 1985. Pricing the Priceless Child: The Changing Social Value of Children. New York: Basic Books.

Zelizer, Viviana A. 1994. The Social Meaning of Money. New York: Basic Books.

About this series. This article belongs to a ten-part series on the anthropology of contemporary America published by Global Strategy Files. Each study reads a recent social phenomenon in the United States through the tools of anthropology: ritual, kinship, exchange, the body and the sacred.

Driss EFFINA, PhD
Independent Researcher, Global Strategy Files

Free preview
The Q4 2026 Global Outlook

The opening pages of our four country reports: United States, United Kingdom, Japan and China. A free PDF, sent to your inbox.

You will also receive occasional analysis from Global Strategy Files. Unsubscribe in one click, at any time.

author-avatar

About Driss Effina

Dr. Driss Effina is a distinguished economist, prolific author, and geopolitical strategist ‎whose work explores the intersections of power, economics, governance, and global ‎transformation. Holder of a PhD in Economic Sciences, an Engineering Degree in ‎Statistics, and a Master's in Capital Markets, he has dedicated more than two ‎decades to advancing economic research, shaping public policy, and producing works ‎of strategic analysis that have reached readers in over 40 countries.‎ As the founder of Global Strategy Files LLC an independent American publishing ‎house headquartered in Albuquerque, New Mexico Dr. Effina has built one of the ‎most ambitious multilingual geopolitical publishing catalogs of the 2020s, with titles in ‎English, French, Spanish, and German spanning topics from the Gulf monarchies and ‎the Kennedy assassination files to the future of the American economy.‎