The Gift With a Scoreboard
Abstract
Since its foundation in 2010, GoFundMe has helped raise more than 40 billion dollars, most of it in the United States. What began as a tool for personal projects has become, in the words of the anthropologist and public-health scholar Nora Kenworthy, an “informal infrastructure of crisis response”. About a third of the platform’s campaigns have long been medical. In 2024 the number of fundraisers for “essentials” such as rent, utilities and groceries quadrupled; in 2025 it rose by a further 20 percent, and “monthly bills” became the second fastest-growing category. When federal food assistance lapsed during the government shutdown of autumn 2025, food-related fundraisers rose almost sixfold within weeks. Research by Kenworthy and Lauren Berliner has shown that crowdfunding rewards the skilled, the connected and the photogenic, and that it obliges the needy to prove their “deservingness”.
This article builds on that work but asks a different question: what kind of gift is a crowdfunding donation, and what kind of society does it produce? Drawing on Marcel Mauss on the gift, Mary Douglas on the “wounding” of charity, Julian Pitt-Rivers on grace, Didier Fassin and Miriam Ticktin on humanitarian reason, Adriana Petryna on biological citizenship and Émile Durkheim on collective effervescence, it makes five claims. First, crowdfunding revives an old American institution, the public collection for the afflicted, but turns it into a gift with a scoreboard, in which every contribution is recorded and displayed. Second, because the gift cannot be returned, the campaign invents a new counter-gift: the narrative update, through which recipients repay donors in story and gratitude. Third, the campaign text is a secular testimony, a ritual genre with fixed conventions whose function is to neutralise the shame of asking. Fourth, the spread from medical to everyday needs marks the humanitarianisation of domestic poverty: Americans increasingly claim help as objects of compassion rather than as holders of rights. Fifth, in politically charged cases, crowdfunding becomes an agonistic exchange, a modern potlatch in which rival groups measure their solidarity in dollars. Together these features describe an economy of grace operating inside a society of contracts.
Keywords: gift, reciprocity, charity, humanitarianism, deservingness, digital platforms, moral economy, United States
1. Introduction: “I never thought I would be asking”
The campaign pages share a family resemblance. A photograph comes first: a smiling face before the diagnosis, a hospital bed after it, a child holding a parent’s hand, a house reduced to ashes, a family standing in front of a car. Then a title, often a name and a plea: Help Sarah Beat Cancer, Keep the Lights On for the Johnsons, Bring Dad Home. Then a text, which nearly always begins with an apology. “I never thought I would be asking for help.” “This is the hardest thing I have ever had to do.” “We have always been the ones who give.” Then the story: a working life, a sudden blow, a gap between what is owed and what can be paid. Then the goal, expressed in dollars, and a progress bar that shows how much of it has been reached. Below, a list of names and amounts: Linda M., 50 dollars; Anonymous, 25 dollars; The Garcia Family, 200 dollars. And, if the campaign succeeds in holding attention, a series of updates: the surgery went well, the landlord agreed to wait, thank you all, we feel so loved.
Iesha Shepard, a 34-year-old mother in New Orleans interviewed by the Associated Press in December 2025, described her own decision to start a fundraiser to avoid eviction: “That was my last option. I prayed and I did a GoFundMe.” Her words capture both the desperation and the quasi-religious register that surround the practice. They also capture its new ordinariness. In 2025, GoFundMe reported that fundraisers for rent, utilities and groceries had risen by 20 percent, after quadrupling the previous year. Its chief executive, Tim Cadogan, offered a simple diagnosis: “When there’s no other net to catch people, I think GoFundMe is where they often end up.”
The scale of the phenomenon is considerable. GoFundMe, which holds by its own account nearly half of the global crowdfunding market, reports more than 40 billion dollars raised since 2010 and a community of some 200 million donors and organisers. A donation is made, on average, every few seconds. Medical campaigns have represented roughly a third of the total for most of the platform’s history; a large share of the remainder covers funerals, disasters, emergencies and, increasingly, the ordinary costs of living. Smaller platforms, from Christian sites such as GiveSendGo to specialised medical services, fill other niches.
The scholarly literature on crowdfunding, much of it produced by Kenworthy, Berliner and their colleagues, has established three robust findings. First, most campaigns fail: in their 2016 sample of medical campaigns, 90 percent did not reach their goal, raising on average about 40 percent of it; an analysis of half a million GoFundMe medical campaigns over five years found that 88 percent fell short and 16 percent received no donations at all. Second, success is unequally distributed: campaigns from wealthier areas, from people with large social networks and media skills, and from white recipients tend to raise more, while people of colour, and Black women in particular, are under-represented and raise less. Third, crowdfunding imposes on the needy the work of proving their worth, producing what Berliner and Kenworthy called a “worthy illness” and what Kenworthy later analysed as “selective deservingness”.
These findings are important and well documented. This article does not repeat them. It approaches crowdfunding from another angle, that of the anthropology of exchange. Since Marcel Mauss’s Essay on the Gift (1925), anthropologists have known that gifts are never simply transfers of resources. They create relationships, impose obligations, express hierarchies and carry moral meanings that vary from one society to another. To ask what kind of gift a crowdfunding donation is, is to ask what kind of social bond it creates, between whom, and on what terms. The answers reveal a transformation in the American moral economy that goes beyond the failures of the health system or the rising cost of living.
The article proceeds in six steps. Section 2 places crowdfunding in the long history of American collective giving and describes its novelty: the gift with a scoreboard. Section 3 analyses the problem of reciprocity and the invention of the update as counter-gift. Section 4 reads the campaign text as a ritual genre of testimony. Section 5 examines the spread of crowdfunding to everyday needs as a humanitarianisation of domestic poverty. Section 6 turns to agonistic crowdfunding in polarised cases. Section 7 concludes with the notion of an economy of grace.
2. The gift with a scoreboard
2.1 Passing the hat
Crowdfunding is not as new as its technology. American society has long possessed institutions for the collective support of the afflicted. In the farming communities of the nineteenth century, neighbours gathered to raise a barn for a family whose building had burned; the “barn raising” remains a national symbol of mutual aid. Churches took up “love offerings” for members in difficulty. Fraternal orders, from the Odd Fellows to the Prince Hall Masons, and immigrant mutual aid societies collected dues to pay for the sick and to bury the dead. In workplaces, a colleague passed the hat when someone’s child fell ill. In small towns, a jar on the counter of the diner or the gas station, with a photograph and a handwritten note, invited customers to contribute for a neighbour’s operation. Benefit dinners, pancake breakfasts and spaghetti suppers turned misfortune into a community event.
These institutions shared several features. They operated within communities of acquaintance, where givers and receivers knew each other or were linked by a few degrees of separation. They were embedded in relations of long-term reciprocity: the family that received help today might give tomorrow, and everyone knew it. And they were, to a large extent, discreet. The amount each person put into the hat was not announced. The collection jar did not display a list of donors. The giving was collective in its effect but private in its detail.
2.2 What the platform changes
Crowdfunding transforms each of these features. First, it extends the community of giving from acquaintances to networks. A campaign circulates through social media, from the recipient’s friends to their friends’ friends and beyond, reaching people who have no prior relationship with the recipient and will never meet them. The platform reports that fundraisers were shared tens of millions of times in 2025. The ideal of every campaign is to “go viral”, that is, to escape the circle of acquaintance altogether and reach the anonymous crowd.
Second, it detaches the gift from long-term reciprocity. The stranger who gives 20 dollars to a family in another state has no expectation of ever receiving help from them. The relationship begins and ends with the donation. Even within circles of acquaintance, the scale of the sums involved, often thousands or tens of thousands of dollars, exceeds what ordinary reciprocity could repay.
Third, and most distinctively, it makes the gift visible. On most campaign pages, every donation is listed with the donor’s name (unless the donor chooses anonymity) and the amount. A running total and a progress bar display the collective result. Donors are ranked, implicitly or explicitly: some platforms highlight the “top donors” or the most recent contributions. The campaign page is a public ledger of who gave how much.
This visibility has precedents in other societies. In many cultures, gifts at weddings and funerals are recorded in books and sometimes announced publicly, so that the obligation to reciprocate can be tracked across years and generations. In parts of rural China, Yan Yunxiang documented the gift lists in which families record every contribution received at life-cycle ceremonies, to be returned in kind when the giver’s own ceremony comes. The public ledger is a technology of reciprocity: it remembers who owes what to whom.
But the crowdfunding ledger is a register without a return. It records gifts that will never be reciprocated in kind. What, then, is its function? The answer lies in its audience. The ledger is read not by the recipient, who will not repay, but by other potential donors, who see who has already given, and by the donors themselves, whose generosity is displayed to their social networks. The scoreboard transforms the gift from a private act of solidarity into a public performance of virtue. It also creates competition: a campaign that is visibly succeeding attracts more donations, while one that has stalled at a low total discourages new givers. The crowd follows the crowd.
2.3 Concentric circles of giving
The ledger also makes visible something that the anonymous jar concealed: the social structure of giving. A typical campaign page, read from the bottom up, reveals a sequence of concentric circles. The first donations come from the closest kin: parents, siblings, children. Then come friends, colleagues and neighbours. Then, if the campaign travels, acquaintances of acquaintances, members of the recipient’s church or alumni network, and finally strangers drawn by a share or a news story. The amounts often decline as the circles widen: large gifts from family, moderate gifts from friends, small gifts from strangers.
This pattern corresponds closely to what Marshall Sahlins, in Stone Age Economics (1972), described as the spectrum of reciprocity. Close to the centre of a social world, among kin, exchange tends towards generalised reciprocity: gifts are given without calculation, and their return is left vague. In the middle range, among friends and neighbours, balanced reciprocity prevails: gifts are expected to be matched in time. At the periphery, among strangers, exchange becomes impersonal or even competitive. Crowdfunding stretches this spectrum. It asks strangers at the periphery to behave as if they were kin at the centre, giving without expectation of return. The campaign’s success depends on how far it can extend the logic of generalised reciprocity beyond its usual boundaries.
This explains a finding that the quantitative literature has documented without fully interpreting: campaigns succeed when they can mobilise large and prosperous inner circles. The family with many relatives in comfortable circumstances raises more, not only because its members give more, but because a strong inner circle gives the campaign the initial momentum that makes outer circles take notice. The scoreboard rewards those who already possess dense and wealthy kinship networks. Where the inner circle is poor or small, the campaign rarely reaches the crowd.
This is the first claim of this article: crowdfunding revives an old American institution of collective giving, but transforms it into a gift with a scoreboard, extended from communities to networks, detached from reciprocity and made publicly visible. The scoreboard does not record debts to be repaid; it records virtue to be seen. In doing so, it changes the nature of the gift itself.
3. The update as counter-gift
3.1 The problem of the unreturned gift
Mauss’s central discovery was that gifts, which appear free and voluntary, are in fact governed by three obligations: to give, to receive and to reciprocate. A gift that is not returned does not end the relationship; it creates a debt, and with the debt a hierarchy. The receiver who cannot reciprocate is diminished. In the potlatch of the Pacific Northwest, which Mauss analysed, chiefs competed to give more than their rivals could return, and the rival who failed to match the gift lost rank. The gift was a weapon as much as a bond.
Mary Douglas, in her foreword to the English translation of Mauss’s essay, drew a lesson from this for modern charity. A gift that cannot be returned, she wrote, wounds the receiver. The charitable donation, given in the expectation of no return, humiliates as much as it helps, because it denies the recipient the dignity of reciprocity. Modern welfare states, in part, were designed to escape this problem: by transforming help into a right, financed by taxes and administered by impersonal institutions, they removed the personal debt that charity created. The pensioner who receives social security owes no one gratitude.
Crowdfunding reintroduces the personal gift into domains where many Americans had come to expect rights or insurance. It thus reintroduces the problem of the unreturned gift. The recipient of a successful campaign has received money from dozens or hundreds of people, some known, many unknown, and cannot repay them. In Mauss’s terms, the recipient is in debt to the crowd. How is this debt managed?
3.2 Repaying in story
The answer, visible on thousands of campaign pages, is the update. Platforms encourage organisers to post regular updates on the recipient’s situation, and successful campaigns typically include many: news of the surgery, photographs of recovery, reports on the move to a new home, and above all expressions of gratitude. “We are overwhelmed by your generosity.” “Every single donation means the world to us.” “We read every name and every message.” “We will never be able to thank you enough.”
From the point of view of the platform, updates are a fundraising technique: they keep the campaign visible and encourage further donations. From the point of view of the anthropology of exchange, they are something more: a counter-gift. The recipient cannot return money, but can return story, emotion and acknowledgement. The update gives donors what they cannot otherwise obtain: knowledge of the outcome of their gift, a sense of participation in a life they have helped, and public recognition of their generosity. It closes, symbolically, the circle of reciprocity that the money cannot close.
This counter-gift has a specific structure. It is addressed to the crowd as a whole, not to individual donors. It is public, displayed on the same page as the ledger. It is narrative, organised as a story with a beginning (the crisis), a middle (the struggle) and, ideally, an end (the recovery). And it is affective: its currency is emotion, both the recipient’s gratitude and the donor’s satisfaction.
The best evidence that the update functions as a counter-gift is the discomfort that arises when it fails. Campaigns that raise money and then fall silent provoke suspicion and complaint. Donors ask what happened to their money; observers speculate about fraud. The platform’s own guidance stresses transparency and regular communication. The obligation to reciprocate, in Mauss’s sense, has not disappeared; it has been converted into an obligation to narrate.
3.3 The tyranny of the happy ending
The update as counter-gift has a further consequence. Because its value lies in narrative closure, it favours stories that can end well. A successful surgery, a recovered child, a family rehoused: these provide the satisfying conclusion that repays the donor. Chronic illness, disability and permanent poverty do not. Their updates are repetitive and inconclusive: the same need, again, next month. Kenworthy observed that one-time expensive treatments attract more support than ongoing lifelong needs such as insulin. The analysis developed here explains why: the chronic condition cannot produce the counter-gift of a happy ending. It offers donors only the prospect of an endless debt.
The same logic shapes campaigns for death. Funeral fundraisers are among the most common on GoFundMe. They have a peculiar narrative structure: the death has already occurred, and the update can only report the ceremony and thank the donors. But this closure is itself satisfying. The funeral is a bounded event; the gift has a clear purpose and a definite end. In a society that has withdrawn many forms of collective support, the funeral remains one of the occasions on which communities still mobilise to give, perhaps because it is the most final of needs.
This is the second claim of this article: because the crowdfunding gift cannot be returned in kind, it generates a new form of counter-gift, the narrative update, through which recipients repay donors in story, gratitude and closure. This counter-gift favours needs that can end well and disadvantages those that cannot. The structure of reciprocity, not only the inequalities of networks and skills, shapes who is helped.
4. The campaign as testimony
4.1 A ritual genre
Ritual genres are forms of speech with fixed conventions, performed in particular settings to produce particular effects: the wedding vow, the funeral eulogy, the confession, the oath. Their conventions are rarely written down, but they are widely known and strictly observed. A speaker who departs from them is felt to have done something wrong.
The crowdfunding campaign text has become a ritual genre in this sense. Its conventions, identified in Berliner and Kenworthy’s analysis and visible on any browse through the platform, are remarkably consistent. The text opens with a disclaimer of reluctance: the writer never expected to ask, is embarrassed, has always been the one who helps others. It establishes the recipient’s prior virtue: a hard worker, a devoted parent, a pillar of the community, someone who “would give you the shirt off his back”. It narrates a sudden misfortune, emphasising that it was unforeseeable and undeserved. It specifies a concrete need and a precise sum. It expresses hope and faith. It closes with thanks in advance and an invitation to share the campaign even for those who cannot give.
4.2 The Protestant structure of testimony
This structure has a recognisable ancestor in American religious culture: the testimony. In the Puritan congregations of seventeenth-century New England, admission to full church membership required a “relation”, a public account of one’s experience of grace. In the evangelical traditions that dominated American Protestantism from the Great Awakenings onward, the testimony became a central ritual: a believer stands before the congregation and narrates a life of sin or suffering, a moment of crisis, and a deliverance through divine grace. The testimony is not merely a personal story. It is a demonstration of membership in the community of the saved.
The crowdfunding campaign reproduces this structure in secular form. The narrative of prior virtue corresponds to the testimony’s account of the self before the crisis; the sudden misfortune corresponds to the moment of trial; the appeal to the crowd corresponds to the turn towards grace; and the updates narrate deliverance. The religious vocabulary is often explicit: “prayers”, “blessings”, “miracles”, “God is good”. Even campaigns without religious language preserve the underlying form.
Max Weber argued that the Protestant ethic linked worldly conduct to spiritual status: a disciplined, hardworking life was a sign, though never a guarantee, of election. The crowdfunding testimony carries this logic into the economy of help. The emphasis on the recipient’s work ethic and prior self-sufficiency is not incidental. It establishes that the need is not the result of moral failure but of misfortune, and that the recipient belongs among the deserving. The historian Michael Katz traced the long American history of the distinction between the “deserving” and “undeserving” poor; the crowdfunding testimony is its contemporary ritual enactment, performed not before a welfare officer but before the crowd.
4.3 The ritual neutralisation of shame
Why is the disclaimer of reluctance so universal? The theory of the gift supplies the answer. Asking for a gift one cannot return is, in Mauss’s terms, an admission of inferiority. In a culture that prizes self-reliance as highly as the United States does, it is also a threat to one’s standing as a full adult and citizen. The opening apology is a ritual device to neutralise this threat. By declaring that one never wanted to ask, the writer separates the act of asking from his or her identity: the asking is forced by circumstances, not chosen by character. By emphasising that one has always been a giver, the writer reframes the request as a temporary reversal in a lifelong pattern of reciprocity, rather than a sign of dependence.
Berliner and Kenworthy found exactly this rhetoric among campaigners: the repeated insistence that they would not ask “unless I had nowhere else to turn”. Kenworthy’s later interviews revealed its emotional cost. One campaigner, she reported, looked at other campaigns with more tragic stories and felt that his own was “not tragic enough to justify the shame” of asking. The ritual genre, in other words, does not only govern how needs are presented. It governs which needs feel presentable at all.
4.4 The machine-written liturgy
A recent development gives this analysis a new twist. Like other platforms, GoFundMe now offers artificial-intelligence tools that help organisers write their campaigns. According to the company’s 2025 report, these tools were used tens of millions of times in a single year. The organiser enters a few facts, and the machine returns a polished text: an opening that acknowledges the difficulty of asking, a portrait of the recipient’s character, a narrative of misfortune, a specific request and a grateful close.
From the point of view of the platform, these tools democratise campaigning: they give those without writing skills access to the persuasive forms that the better-educated master naturally. Berliner and Kenworthy had shown that success required “medical and media literacies” unequally distributed across the population; the machine promises to equalise them. From an anthropological point of view, something else is also happening. A ritual genre that emerged from below, from the accumulated practice of millions of campaigners, is now being codified and reproduced by a machine trained on that practice. The conventions of the testimony are being fixed into a template, as a liturgy fixes the words of a rite.
Liturgies have a double effect. They make the rite accessible to all, since anyone can recite the prescribed words. But they also empty it of individual expression, since everyone recites the same words. As AI-written campaigns multiply, the testimony risks becoming formulaic, and the crowd may learn to read past its conventions in search of signs of authenticity. The genre will then evolve again, perhaps towards rawer, less polished forms such as the short video, which already accompanies many successful appeals. The history of ritual is full of such cycles, in which a codified form provokes a search for spontaneity that eventually codifies itself in turn.
This is the third claim of this article: the crowdfunding campaign is a secular testimony, a ritual genre descended from Protestant forms of public self-narration, whose conventions serve to demonstrate membership among the deserving and to neutralise the shame of asking for an unreturnable gift. The genre is not imposed by the platform; it emerges from the deep structure of American moral culture.
5. The humanitarianisation of domestic need
5.1 From the hospital to the electricity bill
For most of its history, the dominant image of crowdfunding was medical: the cancer patient, the transplant candidate, the accident victim. The data of 2024 and 2025 show a shift. Fundraisers for essentials, rent, utilities, groceries and car repairs, quadrupled in 2024 and rose by a further fifth in 2025. “Monthly bills” became the platform’s second fastest-growing category. Food banks were the most common community recipients. When the federal Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP) lapsed for many households during the government shutdown of October and November 2025, the platform registered a nearly sixfold spike in food-related campaigns within weeks.
The shift is significant not only because of its scale but because of what it reveals about the logic of the platform. Medical crises have a natural affinity with crowdfunding: they are sudden, dramatic, individual and often visual. Monthly bills are none of these. They are chronic, mundane, structural and shared by millions. That people now crowdfund them suggests that the crowdfunding form has become, for a growing number of Americans, a general recourse for need of every kind. The sociologist Martin Lukk, interviewed about the 2025 data, called the platform’s figures a “barometer of where things are at in terms of desperation”, while warning that they understate need, since many of the most desperate lack the networks or skills to campaign at all.
5.2 Humanitarian reason at home
To understand this shift, it is useful to turn to the anthropology of humanitarianism. Didier Fassin, in Humanitarian Reason (2012), described the rise in contemporary societies of a moral and political logic centred on compassion for suffering. Under this logic, people obtain help not because they are entitled to it as citizens but because their suffering moves others. The suffering body becomes the basis of claims. Miriam Ticktin, studying immigration in France, showed how an “illness clause” allowed undocumented migrants with serious diseases to obtain residence permits, while healthy migrants were refused: the sick body opened doors that political rights could not. She called this a “regime of care”, and warned that it rewards suffering while depoliticising its causes. Adriana Petryna, studying Ukrainians exposed to Chernobyl radiation, coined the term biological citizenship for the way in which damaged bodies became the basis of claims on the state.
Crowdfunding imports this humanitarian logic into domestic social life. The campaigner does not claim help as a right; there is no right to have one’s rent paid by strangers. The campaigner claims help as an object of compassion, by displaying suffering in images and narratives designed to move the crowd. The photographs of hospital beds, the descriptions of children going hungry, the videos posted on TikTok to accompany eviction appeals, are the domestic equivalent of the humanitarian imagery that Fassin analysed in international crises. The citizen in need is invited to present herself not as a member of a political community with entitlements but as a victim whose pain can elicit a gift.
This transformation has a paradoxical relationship with the state. GoFundMe’s executives insist that the platform is not a substitute for public programmes and that strong government safety nets are desirable. Yet the platform’s growth tracks the gaps in those programmes, and its data are increasingly read as a map of where the state has withdrawn or failed. During the SNAP lapse, the crowd briefly took over a function of the federal government, but only for those who could make their hunger visible and moving. The humanitarian logic, as Ticktin warned, rewards the most compelling sufferers rather than the most numerous.
5.3 The algorithm as almoner
There is also a new intermediary. In earlier forms of charity, the decision about who deserved help was made by identifiable people: the parish priest, the charity organisation society’s visitor, the welfare caseworker. In crowdfunding, it is made by the combination of a crowd and an algorithm. The platform’s ranking systems determine which campaigns appear in searches and recommendations; social media algorithms determine which posts circulate; and the crowd, responding to what it sees, determines which campaigns succeed. The medieval almoner, who distributed a lord’s charity to the poor at the gate, has been replaced by a distributed system that no one controls and whose criteria no one fully knows.
5.4 The business of grace
One further feature distinguishes crowdfunding from the older institutions of collective giving: the intermediary is a company. GoFundMe is a for-profit enterprise. It has, in recent years, removed its percentage platform fee for personal campaigns in the United States, earning its revenue instead from payment-processing charges and from optional “tips” that donors are invited to add to their gifts. The parish collection plate had no shareholders; the crowdfunding platform does.
Mauss would not have been surprised. His essay ended with a reflection on the persistence of the gift within market societies, and on the hybrid forms in which commerce and generosity mingle. The crowdfunding platform is such a hybrid: a business whose product is the facilitation of gifts. Its commercial interest lies in maximising the volume of giving, which aligns, up to a point, with the interests of recipients. But it also lies in maximising the number of campaigns, the frequency of sharing and the emotional intensity of appeals, since these drive traffic and donations. The platform thus has a structural interest in the expansion of the economy of need. Its executives speak sincerely of the “power of help”, and its tools genuinely assist millions. But the institution that profits from the gaps in the safety net cannot be expected to campaign for closing them.
The tip itself is a revealing artefact. When a donor is invited to add a percentage to “support the platform”, the gift to the recipient is doubled by a gift to the intermediary. In anthropological terms, the platform presents itself not as a vendor of services but as a participant in the circle of generosity, a recipient of gratitude in its own right. The language of help covers the commercial transaction, and the donor who tips experiences the payment as one more act of kindness. This blending of gift and commerce is not a deception; it is the characteristic form of what might be called the business of grace.
This is the fourth claim of this article: the spread of crowdfunding from medical emergencies to everyday needs marks the humanitarianisation of domestic poverty, in which Americans increasingly claim help as objects of compassion rather than as holders of rights, and in which the allocation of help is entrusted to a crowd guided by algorithms. The suffering body, and increasingly the struggling household, becomes the basis of a claim that is neither a right nor a market transaction, but an appeal for grace.
6. Agonistic crowdfunding: the potlatch of the culture wars
6.1 Duelling campaigns
In the spring of 2025, two cases illustrated a different side of crowdfunding. In April, in Frisco, Texas, a seventeen-year-old high school student, Karmelo Anthony, was charged with murder after the fatal stabbing of another student, Austin Metcalf, at a track meet. A fundraiser for Anthony’s legal defence raised several hundred thousand dollars, while the Metcalf family’s supporters also raised funds. A few weeks later, in Rochester, Minnesota, a woman named Shiloh Hendrix was filmed using a racial slur against a five-year-old Black boy at a playground. She launched a campaign on GiveSendGo, a Christian crowdfunding site, saying that she needed to protect and relocate her family after her personal details were published online. It raised more than 700,000 dollars in about a week. The local chapter of the NAACP launched a counter-campaign for the child’s family, which raised more than 300,000 dollars before closing at the family’s request.
Commentators on both sides read these campaigns in explicitly tribal terms. Supporters of each campaign presented their donations as acts of solidarity with their own side and defiance of the other; critics presented the opposing donations as rewards for wrongdoing. Similar patterns had appeared earlier: large defence funds for Kyle Rittenhouse in 2020 and for Daniel Penny in 2023, and, from a very different political direction, a legal defence fund for Luigi Mangione, accused of killing a health-insurance executive in December 2024, which raised more than a million dollars. In each case, the campaign became a site of political confrontation, and the running total a measure of the strength of each camp.
6.2 The potlatch logic
Mauss’s analysis of the potlatch is illuminating here. In the potlatch, the gift was not an expression of solidarity between giver and receiver, but a competition between rival groups, each seeking to demonstrate its wealth and standing by giving more than the other could match. The value of the gift lay less in its benefit to the recipient than in what it said about the giver’s group.
Agonistic crowdfunding follows the same logic. The donor to a politically charged campaign is not primarily concerned with the recipient’s material needs; many donors explicitly describe their gift as a statement. The amount raised becomes a symbolic score, compared publicly with the amount raised by the rival campaign. The gift is addressed less to the recipient than to the other side. And the scoreboard, which in ordinary campaigns displays virtue, here displays strength: the ability of a community to mobilise money in defence of one of its own, or against what it perceives as an injustice.
Émile Durkheim’s concept of collective effervescence adds a further dimension. Durkheim argued that religious rituals produce intense collective emotions that bind participants together and renew their sense of belonging to a group. Agonistic campaigns produce a comparable effervescence online: a rush of donations, shared on social media with expressions of defiance or solidarity, in which participants feel themselves part of a larger collective. The donation becomes a ritual act of membership, and the recipient a totem around whom the group gathers.
6.3 The gift as weapon
This agonistic use reveals a feature of the gift that the warm language of “help” obscures. As Mauss insisted, the gift has always been double: a bond and a weapon, a means of creating solidarity within groups and of asserting superiority over others. Crowdfunding platforms, designed to channel compassion, have proved equally effective at channelling antagonism. The same infrastructure that pays a stranger’s medical bills can fund a culture war. The platforms themselves have been drawn into the conflict, with mainstream sites removing some campaigns and alternative sites such as GiveSendGo presenting themselves as havens for causes that others reject.
This is the fifth claim of this article: in politically charged cases, crowdfunding becomes an agonistic exchange, a potlatch of the culture wars in which rival groups measure their solidarity and strength in dollars. The scoreboard that displays virtue in ordinary campaigns displays power in these cases. The gift, in American digital culture, has recovered its ancient double nature.
7. Conclusion: an economy of grace in a society of contracts
7.1 Grace
The anthropologist Julian Pitt-Rivers, in an essay on “the place of grace in anthropology”, drew attention to a category of exchange that escapes both the market and the reciprocal gift: grace, the gratuitous favour, given without obligation and without calculation, which creates a bond precisely because it was not owed. Grace belongs to the domain of the unpredictable. It cannot be demanded; it can only be hoped for. In Mediterranean societies that Pitt-Rivers studied, grace coexisted with the contractual and the reciprocal, governing relations of patronage, hospitality and favour.
The crowdfunding economy is, in Pitt-Rivers’s sense, an economy of grace. Its gifts are not owed. They are not reciprocal in the strict sense. They depend on the unpredictable responses of strangers to stories they encounter by chance. The campaigner cannot demand; he or she can only hope, pray and share. The outcome resembles a lottery: a few campaigns raise far more than they asked, most raise much less, and some raise nothing at all.
7.2 Grace in a society of contracts
What makes the American case distinctive is that this economy of grace operates within a society otherwise organised by contracts. Americans are insured, employed, indebted and protected through an extraordinarily dense web of formal agreements: health insurance policies, employment contracts, leases, loans, public programmes with precise eligibility rules. Crowdfunding appears in the gaps of this web, where contracts fail to cover what life demands: the deductible the insurance did not pay, the treatment the plan excluded, the rent the wages could not meet, the food the programme stopped providing. In those gaps, the American turns from the contract to grace.
The growth of crowdfunding is thus a measure of the size of the gaps. It also changes the culture that surrounds them. A society that relies increasingly on grace to cover essential needs teaches its members to see help as something to be earned through performance rather than claimed as a right, to present themselves as sufferers rather than as citizens, and to compete for the attention of the crowd. Kenworthy’s warning, that crowdfunding trains Americans to see health care as a personal good to be earned rather than a universal right, can be extended to the whole domain of need.
7.3 What the crowd reveals
Yet the economy of grace also reveals something admirable about American society. Hundreds of millions of donations, most of them small, given by ordinary people to strangers, testify to an enormous reservoir of generosity. The barn raising has not disappeared; it has moved online and expanded to a continental scale. The capacity of Americans to mobilise for one another, outside and sometimes against the institutions, remains one of the distinctive features of their civic culture, as Tocqueville noted in the 1830s.
The question is whether this generosity can be channelled into forms that do not wound, in Mary Douglas’s sense: forms that do not require the needy to perform their suffering, that do not reward the photogenic over the chronic, that do not turn the gift into a weapon. Mutual aid networks, community funds and reformed public programmes all offer possible models. What is clear is that the scoreboard, the testimony and the potlatch are not neutral features of a technology. They are expressions of a moral economy in transition, in which the oldest forms of the gift are returning to a society that thought it had replaced them with rights.
References
Berliner, Lauren S. and Nora J. Kenworthy. 2017. “Producing a Worthy Illness: Personal Crowdfunding Amidst Financial Crisis.” Social Science & Medicine 187: 233-242.
Douglas, Mary. 1990. “Foreword: No Free Gifts.” In Marcel Mauss, The Gift: The Form and Reason for Exchange in Archaic Societies, vii-xviii. London: Routledge.
Durkheim, Émile. 1995 [1912]. The Elementary Forms of Religious Life. New York: Free Press.
Fassin, Didier. 2012. Humanitarian Reason: A Moral History of the Present. Berkeley: University of California Press.
GoFundMe. 2025. 2025 Year in Help. San Diego: GoFundMe.
Katz, Michael B. 1989. The Undeserving Poor: From the War on Poverty to the War on Welfare. New York: Pantheon.
Kenworthy, Nora. 2024. Crowded Out: The True Costs of Crowdfunding Healthcare. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
Kenworthy, Nora, Zhihang Dong, Anne Montgomery, Emily Fuller and Lauren Berliner. 2020. “A Cross-Sectional Study of Social Inequities in Medical Crowdfunding Campaigns in the United States.” PLoS ONE 15 (3): e0229760.
Mauss, Marcel. 1990 [1925]. The Gift: The Form and Reason for Exchange in Archaic Societies. London: Routledge.
Petryna, Adriana. 2002. Life Exposed: Biological Citizens after Chernobyl. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Pitt-Rivers, Julian. 2011 [1992]. “The Place of Grace in Anthropology.” HAU: Journal of Ethnographic Theory 1 (1): 423-450.
Sahlins, Marshall. 1972. Stone Age Economics. Chicago: Aldine-Atherton.
Ticktin, Miriam. 2011. Casualties of Care: Immigration and the Politics of Humanitarianism in France. Berkeley: University of California Press.
Tocqueville, Alexis de. 1840. Democracy in America, Volume 2. London: Saunders and Otley.
Weber, Max. 2001 [1905]. The Protestant Ethic and the Spirit of Capitalism. London: Routledge.
Yan, Yunxiang. 1996. The Flow of Gifts: Reciprocity and Social Networks in a Chinese Village. Stanford: Stanford University Press.
Driss EFFINA, PhD
Independent Researcher, Global Strategy Files
The opening pages of our four country reports: United States, United Kingdom, Japan and China. A free PDF, sent to your inbox.
You will also receive occasional analysis from Global Strategy Files. Unsubscribe in one click, at any time.