Decoded

Raising Them Twice

Decoded analysis cover: Raising Them Twice
Anthropology of Contemporary America | Article 6 of 10

Abstract

About 2.5 million American children are being raised by grandparents, other relatives or close family friends without either parent in the home, according to Generations United’s 2025 report on grandfamilies and kinship care. Census data show more than two million grandparents who report being responsible for coresident grandchildren. These families form for painful reasons: parental substance use, incarceration, death, mental illness, military deployment, deportation. They keep children out of a strained foster care system, saving public budgets, by Generations United’s estimate, at least 10.5 billion dollars a year, but most receive little support. The literature on grandfamilies, produced mainly by advocates, social workers and gerontologists, documents their needs: financial hardship, legal obstacles, health problems, the trauma of the children.

This article reads grandfamilies as a revealing transformation of American kinship. Drawing on Esther Goody’s analysis of the components of parenthood, A. R. Radcliffe-Brown on the relationship between alternate generations, Bernice Neugarten on American grandparenting styles, Linda Burton on “off-time” grandmotherhood, Carol Stack’s ethnography of “child-keeping”, Pauline Boss on ambiguous loss, Janet Carsten on relatedness and Signe Howell on “kinning”, it makes five claims. First, grandfamilies decompose parenthood into its component roles, while American law continues to insist on its unity, leaving most kin caregivers without legal standing. Second, they collapse the relationship of alternate generations, transforming grandparents from indulgent allies into figures of authority and depriving them of the grandparenthood they expected. Third, they are organised around an absent middle generation, whose ambiguous presence shapes loyalties, kin terms and hopes. Fourth, they scramble the American life course, placing child-rearing in the years of retirement and often alongside the care of the oldest generation. Fifth, the shift of child welfare policy towards “kin first” placements shows the American state re-traditionalising kinship, enlisting as infrastructure an extended family it long treated as marginal, while declining to pay for most of the work.

Keywords: kinship, grandparenthood, parenthood, fostering, generations, child welfare, life course, United States

1. Introduction: the second time around

The story usually begins with a telephone call. A daughter has been arrested. A son has overdosed. A child protective services worker is at the door of a house where the children have been left alone. A daughter-in-law has died, and the son cannot cope. A deployment order has come. Sometimes the story begins more slowly: the grandchildren stay for a weekend, then a month, then the parents stop coming to pick them up. However it begins, the outcome is the same. A woman in her fifties or sixties, often with a husband, sometimes alone, finds herself raising children again, decades after she raised her own.

These households have acquired a name: grandfamilies. The term, promoted by the advocacy organisation Generations United, designates families in which grandparents, other relatives or close family friends raise children whose parents are not in the home. In the language of child welfare, they are “kinship care” families, divided between “formal” kinship care, in which a child welfare agency has placed the child with relatives, and the much larger “informal” kinship care, in which families have made the arrangement themselves, without the involvement of the state.

The numbers are substantial and stable. Generations United’s annual reports have put the number of children in grandfamilies at about 2.5 million in recent years, roughly 3 percent of American children, according to the Annie E. Casey Foundation’s data. A far larger number of children live in households that include grandparents: the Census Bureau reported that about 6.7 million adults aged 30 and older lived with grandchildren in 2021, most of them in three-generation households with a parent present. Grandfamilies are more common in rural areas and small counties; in some rural counties of Texas, North Carolina or Minnesota, between one resident in twenty and one in fifty is a grandparent raising grandchildren. They are also disproportionately common among Black and American Indian families, reflecting both longer traditions of extended-family child-rearing and the disproportionate impact of incarceration, poverty and child removal on these communities.

The policy literature on grandfamilies is well developed. It documents the financial strain on caregivers, many of whom live on fixed incomes; the legal obstacles they face in enrolling children in school, obtaining medical care or accessing benefits without formal custody; their health problems and exhaustion; the trauma, behavioural difficulties and developmental needs of children who have experienced parental loss or neglect. It advocates for “kinship navigator” programmes, financial assistance, legal aid, respite care and mental health services. Congress passed the Supporting Grandparents Raising Grandchildren Act in 2018, creating an advisory council, and federal rules adopted in 2023 allowed states to license relatives as foster parents under different standards from those for strangers.

This article does not repeat these findings. It asks what grandfamilies reveal about American kinship. Anthropology has studied, across the world, the forms in which children are raised by people other than their parents: fostering, adoption, child circulation, guardianship. It has developed concepts for understanding the components of parenthood, the relations between generations and the ways in which kinship is made and remade. These concepts illuminate aspects of grandfamilies that the policy literature, focused on needs and services, tends to miss.

The article proceeds in six steps. Section 2 examines the decomposition of parenthood. Section 3 analyses the collapse of alternate generations. Section 4 turns to the absent middle generation. Section 5 considers the scrambling of the life course. Section 6 examines the state’s turn to kin. Section 7 concludes.

2. The decomposition of parenthood

2.1 What is a parent?

In the dominant American cultural model, parenthood is a unity. The parents of a child are the people who conceived the child, who raise the child, who have legal authority over the child, who are financially responsible for the child, and who transmit to the child their name, their inheritance and their identity. All these roles are expected to coincide in the same two people, ideally a married couple. David Schneider’s analysis of American kinship showed how this model joins “blood”, the biological relation, with “law”, the code of conduct, in the figure of the parent.

The anthropologist Esther Goody, in her comparative study of fostering in West Africa, Parenthood and Social Reproduction (1982), challenged the universality of this model. She showed that parenthood could be decomposed into distinct roles: bearing children, the biological act of procreation; bestowing status, the conferral of a name, lineage membership and rights of inheritance; nurturing, the provision of food, shelter and care; training, the transmission of skills and moral education; and sponsoring, the support of the child’s entry into adult life, through marriage, occupation or social position. In many societies, these roles were distributed among several people. Among the Gonja of northern Ghana, whom Goody studied, children were commonly sent to be raised by relatives, who nurtured and trained them, while the biological parents retained their status-giving roles. Fostering was not a sign of family failure but a normal mechanism for distributing children, strengthening ties between kin and providing the old with help.

2.2 Grandfamilies as decomposed parenthood

Grandfamilies are, in Goody’s terms, families in which parenthood has been decomposed. The biological parents remain the child’s parents in the sense of bearing and, usually, of status: the child carries their name, belongs to their lineage, and may inherit from them. But the grandparents nurture, train and sponsor. They feed and house the child, enforce discipline, help with homework, take the child to the doctor, attend school meetings, teach values and prepare the child for adulthood. The functions of everyday parenthood are performed by people who are not, in the cultural model, the parents.

What distinguishes the American case from the West African one is that this decomposition is not culturally recognised as normal. It is experienced as a disruption, the consequence of a parental failure, and it is managed by institutions designed for the unified model. This is most visible in law. American family law assigns parental rights and responsibilities to the legal parents, unless a court transfers them through adoption, guardianship or custody. A grandmother who raises her grandchildren without a court order has, in law, no authority over them. She cannot sign a school enrolment form, consent to medical treatment, obtain a passport or, in many cases, access benefits on the child’s behalf. Studies have long found that most grandparents raising grandchildren have no formal legal arrangement. The Census Bureau’s analysis of the 2000 census found that fewer than one in five did, and advocates report that informal arrangements remain the norm.

2.3 The costs of indivisibility

The insistence of American law on the indivisibility of parenthood creates a gap between social reality and legal form. Grandfamilies perform parenthood without possessing it. To close the gap, they must go to court, which is expensive, slow and often emotionally devastating, because obtaining custody or guardianship may require proving that one’s own child is an unfit parent, or terminating that child’s parental rights in the case of adoption. Many grandparents refuse to take this step, not only because of cost but because it would mean formally declaring their son or daughter a failure, or severing the parent’s legal tie to the child in a way that seems to close the door on reunification.

Some states have responded with intermediate legal instruments: “consent” affidavits allowing caregivers to enrol children in school or obtain medical care; “standby” or “kinship” guardianship that does not terminate parental rights; and “de facto custodian” statuses recognising those who have raised a child for a period of time. These instruments represent, in anthropological terms, a cautious legal recognition of decomposed parenthood: an acknowledgement that the roles of parenthood can be distributed among different people without being concentrated in a single legal parent. But they are patchy, vary widely among states, and remain unknown to many families who could use them.

2.4 Child circulation in comparative perspective

The American unease with decomposed parenthood looks exceptional when placed in comparative perspective. Across much of the world, the movement of children between households has been a normal feature of kinship. The anthropologist Jessaca Leinaweaver, in her study of Andean Peru, The Circulation of Children (2008), described how children were sent to live with grandparents, godparents or relatives in the city, both to relieve poor households and to give children opportunities, and how this “circulation” built and maintained relationships among kin. In the Caribbean, children are commonly raised for periods by grandmothers while mothers work elsewhere, sometimes abroad. In Oceania, adoption and fostering among kin were so common in some societies that a large share of children grew up in households other than those of their birth parents, without stigma.

In these systems, the circulation of children was not a response to failure but a way of distributing the work and the rewards of child-rearing across a kin group. Grandparents received company, help and continuity; parents received relief; children received care and connections. The relationships created by circulation were valued in themselves, and the child who had been raised by a grandmother had two homes rather than none.

American grandfamilies share the structure of child circulation but not its meaning. They form because of crisis rather than strategy, and they are experienced as a disruption of the normal order rather than as part of it. This difference matters. Where circulation is normal, the child raised by a grandmother carries no stigma, and the parents retain their standing. Where it is abnormal, the child must explain, at school and among friends, why he does not live with his parents, and the parents bear the mark of failure. The comparative record suggests that the burdens of American grandfamilies are not inherent in the arrangement itself, but are compounded by a culture that has no place for it.

This is the first claim of this article: grandfamilies decompose parenthood into the component roles that Esther Goody identified, distributing the nurturing, training and sponsoring of children to grandparents while the biological parents retain their status. American law, built on an indivisible model of parenthood, leaves most kin caregivers without legal standing, and closing the gap requires them to perform a legal and moral act, declaring their own children unfit, that many cannot bring themselves to perform.

3. The collapse of alternate generations

3.1 Grandparents as allies

One of the most robust findings of comparative anthropology concerns the relationship between alternate generations. A. R. Radcliffe-Brown, in his studies of kinship systems in Africa and Australia, observed that in many societies the relationship between adjacent generations, parents and children, is marked by authority, respect and sometimes avoidance, while the relationship between alternate generations, grandparents and grandchildren, is marked by familiarity, indulgence and even joking. Grandparents and grandchildren are often classed together, addressed by reciprocal terms, allowed to tease each other, and allied against the middle generation that exercises authority over both. In some systems, the grandchild is considered a reincarnation or replacement of the grandparent. Radcliffe-Brown explained this pattern structurally: the parent must discipline the child, which creates tension; the grandparent, freed from this responsibility, can offer the warmth that the parent cannot.

American grandparenthood, in its modern form, conforms closely to this pattern. The psychologists Bernice Neugarten and Karol Weinstein, in a classic 1964 study, identified several styles of American grandparenting and noted the prevalence of the “fun-seeking” style, in which the grandparent’s relationship with the grandchild is centred on leisure, play and mutual enjoyment, with authority left to the parents. The cultural image of the American grandparent, reinforced by advertising and popular culture, is of an indulgent figure who spoils the grandchildren, lets them stay up late, gives them treats and then sends them home. “The best thing about grandchildren,” a familiar saying goes, “is that you can give them back.”

3.2 From ally to authority

Grandfamilies destroy this structure. The grandparent who raises grandchildren cannot give them back. He or she must assume the authority of the middle generation: enforcing bedtimes, imposing discipline, supervising homework, setting limits. The indulgent ally becomes the parental authority. The structural tension that Radcliffe-Brown located between adjacent generations is transferred to the relationship between alternate generations.

Caregivers and children both feel the loss. Grandparents raising grandchildren frequently report that they miss being “just Grandma”: the relationship they had expected, of pleasure without responsibility, has been replaced by the exhausting work of parenting. Many describe grieving for the grandparenthood they will not have. They also report the difficulty of exercising authority over children who still expect the indulgence of the old relationship, and who may resent the new rules. Children, for their part, may experience the loss of the grandparent as ally, the one adult who could be relied upon to take their side, and may feel that they have lost both a parent and a grandparent in the same transition.

3.3 The missing buffer

The collapse of alternate generations also removes a buffer that kinship systems provide. In Radcliffe-Brown’s analysis, the alliance between grandparents and grandchildren softens the authority of parents: a child disciplined by a parent can find comfort with a grandparent, and the grandparent can intercede. In a grandfamily, there is no one to play this role. The grandparent is the authority, and the parent, if present at all, is often an unreliable or disruptive figure rather than a source of comfort. Children in grandfamilies thus lack the structural ally that the kinship system would otherwise provide. Some families find substitutes in great-grandparents, aunts or uncles who take on the indulgent role; others do not.

There is a further dimension. The relationship between alternate generations in many societies involves a transmission of memory and tradition that differs from that between parents and children. Grandparents tell stories of the family’s past, teach customs and connect children to a longer history. In grandfamilies, this transmission continues, and may even be intensified: grandparents raising grandchildren often see themselves as guardians of family continuity, passing on values and memories that the absent parents cannot. But the transmission now occurs within a relationship burdened by authority, and it competes with the urgent practical tasks of daily child-rearing.

This is the second claim of this article: grandfamilies collapse the relationship of alternate generations, transforming grandparents from indulgent allies, in the pattern that Radcliffe-Brown identified across many societies and that American culture celebrates, into figures of parental authority. Both generations lose the relationship they expected, and the child loses the structural buffer that alternate generations provide.

4. The absent middle

4.1 A kinship structure with a hole

Grandfamilies are defined by an absence: the parents are not in the home. But the absence is rarely complete. In most cases, the parents are alive. They may be in prison, in treatment, in the throes of addiction, struggling with mental illness, deployed overseas, deported, or simply unable or unwilling to care for their children. They may appear intermittently, call occasionally, send gifts or money, make promises of return. They may disappear for years and then reappear. Some die, and their absence becomes final; most remain in a state of uncertain presence.

The family therapist Pauline Boss coined the term ambiguous loss for losses that lack clarity and closure: a person physically absent but psychologically present, as with a soldier missing in action, or physically present but psychologically absent, as with a person with dementia. Grandfamilies live with ambiguous loss of the first kind. The parent is gone from the household but not from the family; the loss cannot be mourned because it is not final; the possibility of return keeps the wound open. Boss observed that ambiguous loss is among the most stressful forms of loss, precisely because it resists resolution.

4.2 Loyalty and hope

The absent middle shapes the emotional structure of grandfamilies in several ways. Children often maintain intense loyalty to their absent parents, idealising them, defending them against criticism and hoping for their return. They may experience their grandparents’ authority as a betrayal of their parents, or feel guilty for loving the grandparents who have replaced them. Grandparents, for their part, are caught between their roles as parents of the absent parent and as parents of the child. They may grieve for their own son or daughter while protecting the grandchild from that son or daughter’s behaviour. They may hope for reunification while fearing it. They may feel anger at their child for abandoning the grandchildren, and guilt at having raised a child who could do so.

The middle generation’s absence also structures the family’s relationship with institutions. When the parent is incarcerated, the family’s life is organised around visits, telephone calls, letters and release dates. When the parent is in treatment, it is organised around the hope of recovery and the fear of relapse. When the parent is deported, it is organised around transnational communication and the possibility of reunion abroad. The absent parent is present through these institutions, which set the rhythm of the family’s hopes.

4.3 What to call Grandma

A small but revealing indicator of the absent middle is kin terminology. Anthropologists have long treated kin terms as windows into kinship structure: what people call each other reveals how they understand their relationships. In grandfamilies, kin terms are often unstable. Children may call their grandmother “Grandma”, “Mom”, “Mom-mom”, “Nana” or some combination, and the choice may change over time. Grandparents report being uncertain whether to encourage or discourage the use of “Mom” or “Dad”, fearing that it would erase the absent parents or confuse the child. Children may call their grandmother “Mom” at school, to avoid explaining their family, and “Grandma” at home. Siblings in the same family may use different terms. The biological parent, when present, may be called by a first name.

This terminological improvisation reflects the structural ambiguity of grandfamilies. The cultural model offers no term for a grandmother who is a mother, or for a mother who is not a parent. Families must improvise, and their improvisations reveal the gap between the kinship roles they actually occupy and the categories their culture provides. Janet Carsten’s concept of relatedness, which emphasises the ways in which kinship is made through everyday practices of living together, feeding and caring, rather than given by birth, helps to understand this. Grandfamilies are making a new form of relatedness, in which the grandparent becomes, in practice, a parent, but they lack the vocabulary to name it.

4.4 The child’s double belonging

For the children, the absent middle produces what might be called a double belonging. They belong to the household in which they live, with its rules, routines and affections, and to the parents who are elsewhere, whose love they may doubt and whose return they may hope for. Advocates and researchers report that children in grandfamilies often carry a heavy emotional load: grief, anger, shame, anxiety about the future and worry about their grandparents’ health and age. A child raised by a 65-year-old grandmother may fear, with good reason, that she will not live to see him grown, and may ask who will care for him if she dies.

This fear points to a structural vulnerability of grandfamilies. Because the caregivers are older, the arrangement has a horizon. The grandmother’s health, energy and life are finite, and the child may face a second loss before reaching adulthood. Some grandfamilies plan for this through “standby” guardianship designations or by identifying a younger relative, an aunt or an older cousin, who will take over. Others do not. The child’s double belonging thus has a temporal dimension: he belongs to a present that may not last and to a past that may not return.

Children also develop strategies for managing their situation in public. Many learn to give short, rehearsed explanations of their family to teachers and classmates, or to avoid the subject altogether. School events such as Mother’s Day or Father’s Day activities, family tree projects and parent-teacher conferences can become occasions of awkwardness. In these moments, the gap between the child’s actual family and the cultural model of the family becomes visible, and the child must perform the work of reconciling them. Grandfamilies thus teach their children, early, a lesson about the distance between how families are imagined and how they are lived.

This is the third claim of this article: grandfamilies are organised around an absent middle generation, whose ambiguous presence, neither fully gone nor present, produces ambiguous loss, divided loyalties and uncertain hopes. The instability of kin terms within these families reveals the gap between the relatedness they are creating and the categories their culture provides.

5. The scrambled life course

5.1 On time and off time

Every society has a model of the life course: an expected sequence of stages, each with its typical age, roles and activities. Sociologists speak of events as “on time” when they occur at the expected age and “off time” when they occur earlier or later. The American life course model, as it took shape in the twentieth century, follows a recognisable script: education in childhood and youth, entry into work and marriage in the twenties, child-rearing in the twenties to forties, the “empty nest” in the fifties, retirement in the sixties, and a period of leisure and grandparenthood in old age. Each stage has its characteristic relationships: the child dependent on parents, the adult raising children, the older adult freed from child-rearing and enjoying grandchildren at a distance.

The sociologist Linda Burton, in her research on young grandmothers in African American families, introduced the concept of “off-time” grandparenthood. She found that women who became grandmothers in their late twenties or thirties, because of early childbearing in two successive generations, often resisted the role, which they felt came too early in their lives. “On-time” grandmothers, who became grandparents in their forties or fifties, were more willing to accept it. The timing of the role shaped its meaning.

5.2 Parenthood in the time of retirement

Grandfamilies create a different kind of off-time event: parenthood in the stage of life that the cultural script reserves for its end. The grandparents who raise grandchildren are typically in their fifties, sixties or seventies. They expected to be finished with child-rearing; many had already experienced the empty nest. They planned for retirement, travel, leisure, perhaps part-time work, perhaps the care of their own ageing parents. Instead, they find themselves attending parent-teacher conferences, driving to soccer practice, helping with algebra homework and navigating the culture of adolescence, often decades after doing so for their own children.

The consequences are both practical and existential. Practically, many grandparents must delay retirement, return to work or stretch fixed incomes to cover the costs of children. They may face health problems that make the physical demands of child-rearing difficult. They must learn a world of childhood that has changed since they raised their own children: new technologies, new educational expectations, new risks. Existentially, they must abandon the life they had imagined for this stage and accept one they did not choose. Many describe a sense of time “out of joint”: living a stage of life that belongs to someone younger.

The off-time quality also affects their social networks. Grandparents raising grandchildren often find themselves isolated from their peers, who are enjoying retirement, and out of place among the parents of their grandchildren’s classmates, who are a generation younger. They belong fully to neither group. Support groups for grandparents raising grandchildren, which have multiplied in recent decades, offer a community of people in the same off-time situation, much as caregiver groups do for those discussed in the previous article.

5.3 The double sandwich

The scrambled life course can produce a particularly heavy configuration. A woman in her sixties raising grandchildren may also have a parent in her late eighties who needs care. She is then caught between two dependent generations: her grandchildren below and her parent above, with her own child, the absent middle, unable to help with either. This “double sandwich” is the extreme form of a broader pattern, in which the longevity of the oldest generation and the difficulties of the middle generation concentrate care obligations on people in their late middle age.

The demographic trends that make this configuration more common are well known: increased longevity, which extends the period during which the oldest generation needs care; and the various crises affecting the parenting generation, from substance use to incarceration to economic instability. The cultural consequence is that the stage of life once imagined as the culmination of the American life course, a period of freedom after the obligations of work and family, has become, for a significant minority, the most burdened stage of all.

This is the fourth claim of this article: grandfamilies scramble the American life course, placing child-rearing in the years the cultural script reserves for retirement and leisure. The resulting off-time parenthood isolates grandparents from their peers, imposes practical and existential costs, and, when combined with the care of the oldest generation, produces a double sandwich in which late middle age becomes the most burdened stage of life.

6. The state turns to kin

6.1 From marginal to central

For much of the twentieth century, American child welfare policy treated extended kin with suspicion. When children were removed from their parents, the preferred placement was with licensed foster families, usually strangers, who had been screened and trained. Relatives were often seen as part of the problem: if the parent had failed, the reasoning went, the family that produced the parent was suspect. Extended-family child-rearing, especially in Black and American Indian communities, was frequently pathologised as a sign of family disorganisation.

The anthropologist Carol Stack, in her classic ethnography All Our Kin (1974), challenged this view. Studying a poor Black community in a Midwestern city, she documented the practice of “child-keeping”, in which children were raised by grandmothers, aunts and other kin, sometimes for long periods, within dense networks of exchange and mutual support. Far from being a sign of disorganisation, child-keeping was an adaptive strategy, a way of pooling scarce resources and ensuring that children were cared for in conditions of poverty and instability. Stack showed that these networks, though invisible to official institutions, were the real structure of family life for many poor Americans.

In the history of American Indian communities, the removal of children by state agencies and placement with non-Native families became so extensive that Congress passed the Indian Child Welfare Act in 1978, establishing a preference for placement with extended family and tribal members. The Supreme Court upheld the law in 2023 in Haaland v. Brackeen, against a constitutional challenge. The law expresses, in legal form, a principle that many Native communities had long practised: that children belong to a wider kin group and a nation, not only to their parents.

6.2 Kin first

Over the past three decades, American child welfare policy has shifted decisively towards kin. Federal law since the 1990s has required states to consider relatives as placement options. The Fostering Connections to Success and Increasing Adoptions Act of 2008 required notification of relatives when children are removed and created a subsidised guardianship option for kin. The Family First Prevention Services Act of 2018 funded kinship navigator programmes. In 2023 the federal Administration for Children and Families adopted a rule allowing states to license kin foster families under separate, more flexible standards than those for non-relatives, removing barriers such as space requirements that had kept many relatives from becoming licensed. Many states now describe their policy as “kin first”: when children must leave their parents, the first option is a relative.

The rationale is both practical and evidence-based. Research suggests that children placed with kin experience greater stability, fewer moves, better maintenance of connections to family and community, and in some studies better behavioural and mental health outcomes than children placed with strangers. Kinship placements are also less costly to the state. And the foster care system has faced chronic shortages of licensed non-relative foster families.

6.3 Re-traditionalising kinship

In anthropological terms, this shift represents a re-traditionalisation of kinship by the state. The extended family, which modern American institutions had marginalised in favour of the nuclear family and the professional foster home, is being enlisted as the primary infrastructure of child protection. The practices that Carol Stack documented among the poor, and that Native communities defended against state removal, are being adopted as policy. The state, which long treated kin networks as a problem, now treats them as a resource.

Signe Howell, in her study of transnational adoption in Norway, used the term kinning for the process by which a child previously unrelated is brought into a kin relationship. The American turn to kin involves a reverse process: not the kinning of strangers but the institutional recognition of kin who were already there. The state classifies, licenses, trains and supervises relatives, transforming informal kin into formal caregivers. In doing so, it reshapes kinship itself, attaching to it new obligations, new forms of surveillance and, in some cases, new resources.

6.4 The unpaid infrastructure

But the re-traditionalisation is incomplete, and its costs are borne largely by families. The vast majority of grandfamilies, those in informal kinship care, are outside the child welfare system and receive none of the payments, services or supports available to licensed foster families. Generations United estimates that for every child in foster care with relatives, many more are being raised by kin outside the system. These families save the public budget billions of dollars a year by caring for children who would otherwise enter foster care, but they do so largely at their own expense. Even within the formal system, relatives often receive lower payments than non-relative foster parents, or none at all if they are not licensed.

The state, in other words, has discovered the extended family as infrastructure without assuming the cost of maintaining it. This parallels the situation of family caregivers for the elderly, described in the previous article: the shadow welfare state of kinship operates at both ends of the life course, caring for the young and the old, and in both cases its labour is largely unpaid and unrecognised.

6.5 The gaze of the state

Formalisation has a further cost, less often discussed: it brings the state’s gaze into the extended family. To become a licensed kinship foster parent, a grandmother must submit to home inspections, background checks, training requirements and continuing supervision by caseworkers. Her house, her finances, her health and her past are examined. Other members of her household may be investigated. The informal relationship of a grandmother and her grandchild becomes an object of administrative scrutiny.

Many grandparents accept this as the price of support. Others refuse it, preferring to raise their grandchildren informally, without payment, rather than open their homes to the state. Their reasons vary: distrust of child welfare agencies, especially in communities with histories of child removal; fear that their own pasts, or those of other household members, will disqualify them; a sense that their family’s business is their own. The informal grandfamily is thus not only a family the state has failed to reach; it is sometimes a family that has chosen not to be reached.

This tension reveals a paradox in the re-traditionalisation of kinship. The state turns to kin because kin offer something that strangers cannot: an existing relationship of love, obligation and belonging. But when the state formalises that relationship, it risks transforming it into something closer to the professional foster care it sought to replace. The grandmother becomes a licensed provider; the grandchild becomes a case; the family becomes a placement. The challenge for policy is to support kin without converting them into agents of the state, to give resources without imposing a gaze that many families experience as intrusion.

This is the fifth claim of this article: the shift of American child welfare policy towards “kin first” placements shows the state re-traditionalising kinship, enlisting as infrastructure an extended family it long treated as marginal, and adopting as policy the practices of child-keeping that poor and Native communities had long sustained. But the re-traditionalisation is incomplete: most kin caregivers remain outside the system, unpaid and unsupported.

7. Conclusion: the extended family returns

Grandfamilies are often presented as a symptom: of the opioid epidemic, of mass incarceration, of family breakdown. They are that, in part. But they are also a revelation. They show that American kinship, for all its official emphasis on the nuclear family and the independent household, retains a capacity for extended-family care that comes into play when the nuclear family fails. They show that parenthood can be decomposed and distributed, as it is in many societies. They show that the relationship between generations can be rearranged under pressure. And they show that the American state, after decades of preferring strangers, has come to rely on kin.

The anthropological perspective developed here suggests that grandfamilies are part of a broader return of the extended family in American life, visible also in the re-kinning of migration and the shadow welfare state of family caregiving discussed in earlier articles of this series. This return is driven less by cultural preference than by necessity: the failures of the market and the state to provide care, the crises affecting the parenting generation, the costs of housing and childcare. It produces families that are stronger in some ways and more burdened in others.

What grandfamilies need, the policy literature rightly insists, is support: legal tools that recognise decomposed parenthood without forcing families to declare their children unfit, financial assistance comparable to that available to foster families, respite, health care, mental health services and community. What American culture needs, this article suggests, is a recognition that the model of the self-sufficient nuclear family was never the whole story of American kinship. Behind it, and beneath it, there has always been another family, extended, improvised and resilient, ready to take in the children when the parents cannot. That family is now carrying a substantial share of the nation’s children. It deserves to be seen.

References

Boss, Pauline. 1999. Ambiguous Loss: Learning to Live with Unresolved Grief. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.

Burton, Linda M. 1996. “Age Norms, the Timing of Family Role Transitions, and Intergenerational Caregiving Among Aging African American Women.” The Gerontologist 36 (2): 199-208.

Carsten, Janet, ed. 2000. Cultures of Relatedness: New Approaches to the Study of Kinship. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Generations United. 2025. The Costs of Caregiving: Why Supporting Grandfamilies and Kinship Care Is Good for Children and Our Nation’s Economy. 2025 State of Grandfamilies and Kinship Care Report. Washington, DC: Generations United.

Goody, Esther N. 1982. Parenthood and Social Reproduction: Fostering and Occupational Roles in West Africa. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Howell, Signe. 2006. The Kinning of Foreigners: Transnational Adoption in a Global Perspective. New York: Berghahn.

Leinaweaver, Jessaca B. 2008. The Circulation of Children: Kinship, Adoption, and Morality in Andean Peru. Durham: Duke University Press.

Neugarten, Bernice L. and Karol K. Weinstein. 1964. “The Changing American Grandparent.” Journal of Marriage and the Family 26 (2): 199-204.

Radcliffe-Brown, A. R. 1952. Structure and Function in Primitive Society. London: Cohen and West.

Schneider, David M. 1968. American Kinship: A Cultural Account. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall.

Stack, Carol B. 1974. All Our Kin: Strategies for Survival in a Black Community. New York: Harper and Row.

United States Census Bureau. 2024. “Grandparents Living with Grandchildren.” America Counts story, March 19. Washington, DC: Census Bureau.

About this series. This article belongs to a ten-part series on the anthropology of contemporary America published by Global Strategy Files. Each study reads a recent social phenomenon in the United States through the tools of anthropology: ritual, kinship, exchange, the body and the sacred.

Driss EFFINA, PhD
Independent Researcher, Global Strategy Files

Free preview
The Q4 2026 Global Outlook

The opening pages of our four country reports: United States, United Kingdom, Japan and China. A free PDF, sent to your inbox.

You will also receive occasional analysis from Global Strategy Files. Unsubscribe in one click, at any time.

author-avatar

About Driss Effina

Dr. Driss Effina is a distinguished economist, prolific author, and geopolitical strategist ‎whose work explores the intersections of power, economics, governance, and global ‎transformation. Holder of a PhD in Economic Sciences, an Engineering Degree in ‎Statistics, and a Master's in Capital Markets, he has dedicated more than two ‎decades to advancing economic research, shaping public policy, and producing works ‎of strategic analysis that have reached readers in over 40 countries.‎ As the founder of Global Strategy Files LLC an independent American publishing ‎house headquartered in Albuquerque, New Mexico Dr. Effina has built one of the ‎most ambitious multilingual geopolitical publishing catalogs of the 2020s, with titles in ‎English, French, Spanish, and German spanning topics from the Gulf monarchies and ‎the Kennedy assassination files to the future of the American economy.‎