Sober Company
Abstract
In July 2026, for the second year running, only 54 percent of American adults told Gallup that they ever drink alcohol, the lowest share since the polling organisation first asked the question in 1939. As recently as 2022 the figure had been 67 percent; in the late 1970s it reached 71 percent. Among adults aged 18 to 34, only half now drink, against nearly six in ten in 2023. A majority of Americans now believe that even moderate drinking, one or two drinks a day, is bad for health, a view held by barely a quarter a decade ago. Sales of non-alcoholic beer, wine and spirits have passed a billion dollars a year in stores, and hemp-derived THC beverages grew into a fast-expanding category before a federal limit, first scheduled for 12 November 2026 and then postponed by Congress to 11 December, threatened to remove most of them from the market. Commentators explain the shift by health concerns, the cost of alcohol, the rise of cannabis, social media and the reduced in-person socialising of the young.
This article asks what happens to social life when its oldest lubricant is withdrawn. Drawing on Craig MacAndrew and Robert Edgerton on drunken comportment, Ruth Benedict on Dionysian and Apollonian cultures, Mary Douglas on “constructive drinking”, Marcel Mauss on reciprocity, Erving Goffman on face and passing, Victor Turner on communitas and Ray Oldenburg on “third places”, it makes five claims. First, the decline of drinking removes a culturally licensed time-out, the zone of permitted disinhibition in which Americans flirted, confessed and transgressed, and obliges sociability to function without its customary excuse. Second, it marks a shift from a Dionysian to an Apollonian ethos, carried by a new temperance that, unlike the old, is secular, individual and medical rather than religious, collective and moral. Third, non-alcoholic drinks preserve the form of drinking rituals while emptying them of their substance, allowing abstainers to take part in the toast and the round without the drink. Fourth, the brief rise of THC beverages and their federal restriction reveal an unresolved politics of the licit intoxicant: a society deciding which substance, if any, it will sanction for collective pleasure. Fifth, sociability is relocating from the night to the day and from the bar to the activity, as run clubs, daytime dance parties and other sober rituals take over some of the functions of the drinking place.
Keywords: alcohol, sociability, ritual, reciprocity, temperance, intoxication, third places, United States
1. Introduction: half a nation dry
In 2026 Gallup’s annual Consumption Habits survey delivered a result that confirmed a historic change. The share of American adults who said they “ever have occasion to use alcoholic beverages”, which had hovered in the low to mid sixties for four decades, stood at 54 percent for the second consecutive year. The decline since 2023 was visible across most demographic groups. Women’s drinking had fallen more than men’s. Young adults, once the heaviest drinkers, were now the least likely to drink: only 50 percent of those aged 18 to 34 did so. The share who said they sometimes drink more than they should reached a record low of 13 percent. And for only the second time since Gallup began asking in 2001, a majority, 51 percent, said that one or two drinks a day were bad for a person’s health. The only group whose drinking had not declined was the most religious, those attending services weekly, who already drank less.
The change has many signs in daily life. Bars and restaurants report lower alcohol sales and more requests for alternatives. Breweries, wineries and distillers face declining volumes. Non-alcoholic beer reached a record share of grocery beer sales during “Dry January” 2026, and non-alcoholic beer, wine and spirits together passed a billion dollars in annual sales in stores tracked by NielsenIQ. Online grocers have dropped alcohol from their shelves; non-alcoholic bottle shops have opened in several cities. Bartenders compete to create elaborate “zero-proof” cocktails. Dating apps allow users to signal that they are “sober curious”. In January 2025 the outgoing Surgeon General issued an advisory linking alcohol to several types of cancer and calling for warning labels.
Explanations are abundant. Health concerns, amplified by the Surgeon General’s advisory and by a wellness culture that treats the body as a project, are the most commonly cited. The cost of alcohol, especially in bars and restaurants, is another. The legalisation of cannabis in many states has offered an alternative intoxicant. The decline of in-person socialising among the young, often attributed to smartphones and social media, reduces the occasions for drinking. GLP-1 medications, discussed in the third article of this series, reduce the desire for alcohol as well as food. Generational change, as cohorts with different habits replace one another, plays a part.
This article does not seek to rank these causes. It asks what the decline of drinking means for the forms of social life that alcohol has sustained. In almost every society that has known it, alcohol has been not merely a substance consumed but a social institution, embedded in rituals of hospitality, celebration, mourning, courtship, work and politics. Anthropologists have studied drinking for more than a century, and their central finding is that the effects of alcohol on behaviour are shaped as much by culture as by pharmacology. If that is so, then a society that drinks less must reorganise the cultural work that drinking performed.
The article proceeds in six steps. Section 2 examines the loss of the culturally licensed time-out. Section 3 analyses the shift from a Dionysian to an Apollonian ethos. Section 4 turns to the persistence of ritual form in non-alcoholic drinking. Section 5 considers the politics of the licit intoxicant. Section 6 examines the relocation of sociability. Section 7 concludes.
2. The end of the time-out
2.1 Drunken comportment
In 1969 the anthropologists Craig MacAndrew and Robert Edgerton published Drunken Comportment, a comparative study that overturned the common assumption that alcohol simply “releases inhibitions”. Surveying ethnographic reports from many societies, they found that people’s behaviour when drunk varied enormously from one culture to another. In some societies, drinking led to aggression; in others, to placidity; in some to sexual licence, in others to none. Within a given society, drunken behaviour followed rules: people did not do just anything when drunk, but specific things, within culturally defined limits. The disinhibiting effects of alcohol, MacAndrew and Edgerton concluded, were largely learned. Societies taught their members how to be drunk.
Their central concept was the time-out. In many societies, drunkenness is understood as a state in which the ordinary rules of conduct are partly suspended. The drunk person is not held fully responsible for what he or she does; behaviour that would otherwise be sanctioned is excused, within limits. “I was drunk” is an explanation that, in such societies, partly exonerates. The time-out is, in Victor Turner’s terms, a liminal zone: a temporary suspension of structure in which people can behave in ways that ordinary life forbids.
2.2 What the time-out did
American drinking culture has made extensive use of the time-out. Alcohol has provided the licensed context for a wide range of social behaviours that ordinary norms make difficult. Flirtation and courtship have been closely tied to drinking: the bar, the party and the date over drinks are the classic settings in which Americans have approached romantic and sexual partners, with alcohol lowering the social risk of rejection and offering an excuse for boldness. Confession and intimacy have also been licensed by drink: the late-night conversation in which friends reveal what they would not say sober, the office party at which colleagues express what the workplace suppresses. Conflict and reconciliation, joking and teasing, the crossing of hierarchies, the boss drinking with the employees, have all taken place in the space alcohol provided.
The time-out also structured transitions in the life course. The rite of passage of the twenty-first birthday, the legal drinking age, involved ritual drinking; the college years were marked by a culture of heavy drinking that functioned, among other things, as an initiation into adult sociability. The bachelor and bachelorette party, the wedding reception with its open bar, the wake with its drinks in honour of the dead, all used alcohol to mark and manage transitions.
2.3 Sociability without an excuse
When fewer people drink, the time-out shrinks. Sociability must function without its customary excuse. This has consequences that are visible in reports of young adults’ social lives. Dating without alcohol requires a different kind of courage: the first approach, the expression of interest, the first kiss, must be made without the cover of disinhibition. Some young adults describe this as liberating, allowing more honest and conscious relationships; others as daunting. Dating apps, which already moved the first approach from the bar to the screen, have adapted by allowing users to specify drinking preferences and by promoting activity-based dates, coffee, walks, classes, rather than drinks.
Intimacy and confession also change. Without the licensed disinhibition of drink, the late-night revelation must happen in other settings, or not at all. Some observers suggest that the decline of drinking is linked to a broader caution in the social lives of young Americans, a reluctance to take social risks that the time-out once made easier. Others argue that it reflects a preference for forms of intimacy that do not depend on intoxication, and that the confessions made sober are more meaningful.
The decline of the time-out also changes the meaning of transgression. When drunken behaviour was excused, a certain amount of misbehaviour was tolerated as part of social life. In a sober culture, the same behaviour is less excusable. This may contribute to a social climate in which conduct is judged more strictly, and in which the tolerance for error that the time-out provided is reduced.
2.4 Gender and the time-out
The time-out was never neutral with respect to gender. In American drinking culture, the licence that alcohol provided was distributed unequally. Men’s drunken behaviour was often excused in ways that women’s was not; women who drank heavily risked judgements about their respectability that men did not face. And the time-out that licensed male boldness in courtship could also license harassment and assault. Drinking environments, the bar, the fraternity party, the office happy hour, have long been settings in which women had to manage risks that men did not: unwanted advances, drinks tampered with, the difficulty of leaving safely. The time-out excused, in part, the very behaviour that made these environments dangerous.
Gallup’s data show that women’s drinking has fallen faster than men’s since 2023, by about eleven percentage points against five. Many factors may contribute, including the health messages that have emphasised alcohol’s link to breast cancer. But the anthropological perspective suggests another: for many women, the decline of the time-out is not a loss but a gain. Sober sociability removes one of the principal excuses for male misconduct and one of the principal sources of risk in social settings. The rise of a genre of sobriety memoirs and guides written by and for women in the late 2010s and 2020s, presenting abstinence as a form of empowerment rather than deprivation, expresses this view. Holly Whitaker’s Quit Like a Woman (2019), which framed alcohol as a product marketed to women in the language of liberation, is a prominent example.
The gender dimension also affects the meaning of drinking for men. In much of American culture, the ability to drink heavily has been a marker of masculinity, and the refusal of a drink could be read as weakness. The decline of drinking among young men, though less steep than among young women, suggests that this marker is losing some of its force. A masculinity defined by fitness, discipline and self-optimisation, prominent in contemporary online culture, is compatible with sobriety in a way that the masculinity of the beer commercial was not.
This is the first claim of this article: the decline of drinking removes the culturally licensed time-out that, in MacAndrew and Edgerton’s analysis, alcohol has provided in many societies. American sociability must now function without its customary excuse, with consequences for courtship, intimacy, confession and the tolerance of transgression.
3. From Dionysian to Apollonian
3.1 Benedict’s two ethoses
Ruth Benedict, in Patterns of Culture (1934), borrowed from Nietzsche a distinction between two cultural orientations. Dionysian cultures, she argued, seek value in excess, ecstasy and the breaking of ordinary limits, through intoxication, frenzy, visions and ecstatic rituals. Apollonian cultures value moderation, sobriety, measure and restraint, distrusting excess and avoiding intoxication. Benedict contrasted the Pueblo peoples of the American Southwest, whom she described as Apollonian, with the Plains peoples, whom she described as Dionysian, seeking visions through fasting, self-torture and, in some cases, drugs.
Benedict’s typology has been criticised as too schematic, and few anthropologists would apply it today without qualification. But it captures a real dimension of cultural variation: the value a society places on the experience of transcending ordinary consciousness through intoxication or ecstasy. Mainstream American culture in the twentieth century combined elements of both. Its Puritan and temperance traditions were strongly Apollonian; its popular culture of the bar, the party, the spring break and the tailgate was Dionysian. The two coexisted in tension, and the balance shifted over time: the Apollonian triumph of Prohibition in the 1920s was followed by a long Dionysian period, culminating in the high drinking rates of the 1970s.
3.2 The new temperance
The decline of drinking since 2023 marks a shift in the balance towards the Apollonian. But this new temperance differs in important ways from the old. The temperance movement of the nineteenth and early twentieth centuries was religious, rooted in evangelical Protestantism, and moral: drinking was a sin, a cause of poverty, violence and family breakdown, and abstinence was a sign of virtue. It was collective: it sought to change society through law, culminating in the Eighteenth Amendment. And it was organised: through churches, the Woman’s Christian Temperance Union, the Anti-Saloon League and other associations.
The new temperance is, by contrast, largely secular. Gallup’s data show that the decline in drinking since 2023 occurred among the moderately religious and the non-religious, while drinking among the most religious was stable. It is individual rather than collective: it seeks not to change the law but to change personal habits, and it is expressed in individual choices, the “sober curious” lifestyle, the Dry January challenge, the decision to drink less. It is medical rather than moral: drinking is bad not because it is sinful but because it is unhealthy, a toxin that damages the liver, raises the risk of cancer and disturbs sleep. And it is promoted not by churches and temperance societies but by health authorities, wellness influencers, fitness culture and the market for alternatives.
3.3 The body as project
The medical framing of the new temperance connects it to a broader cultural change: the treatment of the body as a project of optimisation. The wellness culture of the 2020s, with its sleep trackers, step counts, biomarker tests, supplements and longevity protocols, encourages individuals to monitor and improve their physical functioning. Alcohol, in this framework, is a pollutant, in Mary Douglas’s sense: a substance that contaminates the body and disrupts its optimal performance. The fitness tracker that shows the effect of a glass of wine on one’s sleep score turns the drink into a measurable harm.
This framing gives the new temperance its particular moral tone. It does not condemn drinkers as sinners. But it does present abstinence or moderation as a form of self-care and self-respect, and heavy drinking as a failure to take care of oneself. The moral judgement is internalised and individualised: one drinks less not to obey God or to save society, but to be one’s best self.
The Apollonian turn is not universal. Drinking remains common, especially among older adults, and the alcohol industry continues to promote Dionysian pleasures. But the cultural centre of gravity has shifted. For a growing number of Americans, especially the young, the ideal of the good life emphasises clarity, control and health over intoxication and release.
3.4 The new map of drinking
The Apollonian turn has redrawn the social map of American drinking in ways that confound older expectations. For most of the twentieth century, the young drank most and the old least. Gallup’s analysis of its long-term data shows that this pattern has reversed: young adults are now less likely than older adults to drink, and older adults, as the baby boom generation replaced the more abstemious Silent Generation, drink more than their predecessors did at the same age. The cohort that came of age in the Dionysian 1960s and 1970s has carried its habits into old age, while its grandchildren have adopted the habits of an older America.
The religious map has also changed. Historically, abstinence in the United States was strongly associated with evangelical Protestantism, Mormonism and other religious traditions that prohibited or discouraged alcohol. In Gallup’s recent data, drinking among the most religious, those who attend services weekly, has been stable at a relatively low level, while the decline since 2023 has come among the moderately religious and the non-religious. Abstinence, once a marker of religious identity, is becoming common among the secular. The sober young professional who has never attended church and the devout evangelical who has never touched alcohol now share a practice, though for entirely different reasons.
Even the political map has shifted. Gallup reported in 2025 that the sharpest decline in drinking since 2023 had occurred among Republicans. The reasons are not clear, and the data are too recent to support firm conclusions. But the finding suggests that the Apollonian turn is not confined to the progressive, urban, wellness-oriented milieu with which it is often associated in media coverage. Concern with health, discipline and self-control, values that cut across partisan lines, appears to be driving the change on both sides of the political divide.
This is the second claim of this article: the decline of drinking marks a shift from a Dionysian towards an Apollonian ethos, in Ruth Benedict’s terms. Unlike the temperance movement of the past, which was religious, collective and moral, the new temperance is secular, individual and medical, rooted in a wellness culture that treats the body as a project and alcohol as a pollutant.
4. The form without the substance
4.1 Drinking as ritual
Mary Douglas, introducing a collection of anthropological essays entitled Constructive Drinking (1987), argued that drinking is not primarily about the substance consumed but about the social world it constructs. Drinks mark occasions, define groups, express relationships and structure time. The choice of what to drink, with whom, when and how, is a system of signs. Drinking occasions are rituals in which participants enact and affirm their social bonds.
American drinking culture has its own rituals. The toast, in which glasses are raised and touched to mark an occasion or honour a person, is among the most widespread. The round, in which members of a group take turns buying drinks for all, is a ritual of reciprocity in Mauss’s sense: each member gives and receives in turn, and the failure to buy one’s round is a breach of social obligation. The happy hour after work, the drink offered to a guest on arrival, the champagne at a wedding, the beer at a sports game, all mark occasions and affirm relationships.
4.2 The non-drinker’s problem
For the non-drinker in a drinking culture, these rituals pose a problem. To refuse a drink is to refuse participation in the ritual, which may be read as a refusal of the relationship, much as the refusal of food, discussed in the third article of this series, may be read as a refusal of hospitality. The non-drinker at the bar, the colleague who declines the round, the guest who turns down the wine, all risk appearing aloof, judgmental or unwell. Non-drinkers have long developed strategies to manage this: holding a glass of soda that looks like a mixed drink, ordering a “virgin” cocktail, inventing excuses (driving, medication, an early morning). These are forms of what Erving Goffman called passing: presenting oneself as conforming to a norm while not actually doing so, in order to avoid stigma.
4.3 The ritual vessel
The explosion of non-alcoholic alternatives transforms the non-drinker’s situation. Non-alcoholic beers, wines and spirits, and elaborate zero-proof cocktails, allow the non-drinker to participate in drinking rituals fully, without passing. The non-alcoholic beer looks like beer, is served in the same glass, can be raised in the same toast and bought in the same round. The zero-proof cocktail is prepared by the same bartender with the same ceremony and served in the same glass as its alcoholic equivalent. The form of the ritual is preserved; only the substance is removed.
This is a remarkable cultural development. It suggests that what matters, in many drinking rituals, is less the alcohol than the form: the glass in the hand, the shared act of drinking, the toast, the round. The non-alcoholic drink is a ritual vessel that allows participation without intoxication. Religious history offers parallels: the substitution of grape juice for wine in the communion services of temperance-minded Protestant churches in the nineteenth century, pioneered by the Methodist dentist Thomas Welch, preserved the form of the sacrament while removing its alcohol. The modern zero-proof cocktail performs a similar substitution in secular rituals of sociability.
The market data support this interpretation. NielsenIQ found that 95 percent of buyers of non-alcoholic drinks also buy alcohol: the alternatives are used not only by abstainers but by drinkers moderating their consumption, alternating alcoholic and non-alcoholic drinks in the same evening or choosing non-alcoholic options on some occasions and alcoholic ones on others. The boundary between drinker and non-drinker, which earlier cultures drew sharply, blurs. Participation in the ritual no longer requires a commitment to intoxication.
This is the third claim of this article: non-alcoholic drinks preserve the form of American drinking rituals, the toast, the round, the glass in the hand, while emptying them of their substance. They function as ritual vessels that allow abstainers and moderators to participate in sociability without intoxication or passing, revealing that much of what drinking rituals accomplished lay in their form rather than their alcohol.
5. The politics of the licit intoxicant
5.1 Every society chooses its drugs
The historian David Courtwright, in Forces of Habit (2001), traced how a handful of psychoactive substances, alcohol, tobacco, caffeine, opium, cannabis, coca, spread across the world in the modern era, and how societies decided which of them to accept, tax and integrate into their social life, and which to prohibit. Anthropologists have long observed that every society has its licit intoxicants, embedded in rituals and regulated by custom, and its illicit ones, associated with deviance and punished by law. The line between them is not drawn by pharmacology alone. It reflects history, religion, economic interests and the social identities of those who use each substance.
In the United States, alcohol has been, for most of its history, the principal licit intoxicant of collective sociability, with a long interruption during Prohibition. Cannabis, prohibited federally since 1937, has been progressively legalised by states since 2012 for medical and then recreational use, though it remains illegal under federal law. Its spread has offered an alternative intoxicant, and Gallup and other surveys have documented rising cannabis use alongside falling alcohol use, especially among young adults. But cannabis, consumed mainly by smoking, vaping or edibles, has not easily fitted into the public rituals of drinking. One does not toast with a joint at a wedding.
5.2 The THC drink interlude
The 2018 federal farm bill, which legalised hemp, defined as cannabis with less than 0.3 percent delta-9 THC by dry weight, opened an unexpected door. Manufacturers discovered that they could produce beverages containing small doses of THC derived from hemp, legally under federal law, and sell them in grocery stores, liquor stores, restaurants and bars. Hemp-derived THC drinks, often marketed as seltzers, sodas and “mocktails” with doses of two to ten milligrams, grew rapidly. NielsenIQ reported that THC beverages reached 239 million dollars in mainstream retail sales in the year to April 2026, up 135 percent, and industry estimates of the full market ran much higher. Minnesota, which in 2022 became the first state to regulate low-dose hemp edibles and drinks, saw them spread to bars and restaurants; arenas began selling them alongside beer.
The THC drink was, in anthropological terms, an attempt to give a new intoxicant a place in the old rituals. It came in a can, was served in a glass, could be raised in a toast and bought in a round. It offered a mild intoxication, a time-out of a different kind, within the forms that alcohol had established. Consumers described it as a way to relax and socialise without a hangover. Some alcohol distributors and retailers embraced it as a lifeline in a declining market.
5.3 Drawing the line
The interlude was brief. In November 2025, the law ending the federal government shutdown included a provision redefining hemp to exclude products containing more than 0.4 milligrams of total THC per container, effective 12 November 2026. The provision, supported by a coalition that included some state attorneys general, parts of the alcohol industry, the licensed cannabis industry in some states and lawmakers concerned about unregulated intoxicating products sold to minors, would effectively remove most intoxicating hemp products, including THC drinks, from the legal market. In the months that followed, industry groups lobbied to delay or replace the ban with a regulatory framework; a majority of state attorneys general urged Congress to hold firm; some states moved to regulate or prohibit the products on their own. In the spring of 2026 the President called on Congress to amend the ban. In September, Congress postponed the restriction for naturally derived hemp products by one month, to 11 December 2026, while letting the prohibition of synthetic cannabinoids take effect on the original date. As this article was written, in early November, whether Congress would replace the ban with a regulatory framework before the new deadline remained uncertain.
The episode illustrates the politics of the licit intoxicant. As alcohol’s hold on American sociability weakens, a space opens for other substances to take its place. Which substances will be allowed to occupy that space, under what rules and with what rituals, is a question that the society has not resolved. Supporters of THC drinks argue that they offer a safer alternative to alcohol and should be regulated like it. Opponents argue that they were a product of a legal loophole, sold without adequate oversight, sometimes to minors, and that intoxicating substances should be controlled by legislation designed for the purpose. Behind both arguments lies the older question that Courtwright identified: which pleasures a society will license, and which it will forbid.
This is the fourth claim of this article: the rise of THC beverages and their federal restriction reveal an unresolved politics of the licit intoxicant. As alcohol’s place in American sociability weakens, a society that has defined itself partly by its drinking must decide which substance, if any, it will sanction for collective pleasure, and in what ritual forms.
6. The relocation of sociability
6.1 The third place
The sociologist Ray Oldenburg, in The Great Good Place (1989), argued that healthy societies need “third places”: informal public gathering spaces, distinct from home (the first place) and work (the second), where people meet regularly, converse and form community. His examples included the English pub, the French café, the German beer garden and the American tavern, along with coffee shops, barbershops and general stores. Many of Oldenburg’s third places were drinking places. The bar, in American life, was one of the principal sites of informal sociability, where regulars gathered, strangers met and community was made.
The decline of drinking threatens these places. Bars and taverns face falling alcohol sales; some have closed, others have adapted by expanding food, games, non-alcoholic menus and events. But the question raised by the decline is not only economic. If drinking places were among the principal third places of American life, where will sociability go when fewer people drink?
6.2 New rituals of communitas
The answer emerging in American cities is that sociability is relocating, from the night to the day, from intoxication to activity. Several new forms have become prominent. Run clubs, which gather groups of mostly young adults for weekly runs followed by coffee or breakfast, have grown rapidly and are widely described as new venues for meeting friends and romantic partners. Daytime dance parties and “sober raves”, sometimes held in the morning before work, often fuelled by coffee rather than alcohol, offer the collective ecstasy of the dance floor without intoxication. Pickleball, the fastest-growing sport in the country, has become a social activity as much as an athletic one. Sauna and cold-plunge clubs, climbing gyms, book clubs, supper clubs, craft workshops and board-game cafés provide structured settings for sociability.
These new forms share several features. They are organised around an activity rather than a substance: the run, the dance, the game, the sauna, the book. They often take place in the daytime or early evening rather than late at night. They emphasise health and self-improvement, consistent with the Apollonian ethos. And they produce, in Victor Turner’s terms, communitas: the sense of shared experience and equality among participants, which in drinking culture was produced by the shared intoxication of the bar.
Émile Durkheim’s concept of collective effervescence is relevant here. Durkheim argued that collective rituals produce intense shared emotions that bind participants together. Drinking was one of the principal sources of collective effervescence in secular modern societies: the shared intoxication of the party, the bar, the festival. The new sober rituals seek effervescence through other means: physical exertion, rhythm and music, the shared heat of the sauna, the competition of the game. The morning dance party, with its caffeine and music, is an explicit attempt to recreate the effervescence of the nightclub without alcohol.
6.3 What is gained and what is lost
The relocation of sociability has gains and losses. Among the gains: activities that improve health, safer settings, especially for women, who have long faced risks in drinking environments, and forms of community that do not depend on a substance with well-documented harms. Among the losses: the spontaneity of the bar, where one could drop in without commitment, and the inclusiveness of the tavern, which welcomed the regular regardless of fitness or skill. Activity-based sociability tends to select for the healthy, the fit and those with time and money for classes and memberships. The neighbourhood bar, for all its problems, was open to everyone who could buy a drink.
There is also a question of depth. The time-out of drinking, discussed in Section 2, allowed forms of intimacy and confession that structured activities may not. The run club conversation is shaped by the run; the pickleball game leaves little room for the late-night revelation. Whether the new forms of sociability can produce the same depth of connection as the old, or will develop their own forms of intimacy, remains to be seen.
6.4 The bar reinvents itself
The drinking place is not simply disappearing; it is adapting. Many bars and restaurants have expanded their non-alcoholic menus, treating zero-proof cocktails with the same craft and pricing as their alcoholic counterparts. Some have added activities, trivia nights, karaoke, board games, live music, to give customers reasons to come that do not depend on drinking. A small number of “sober bars” have opened in cities such as New York, Chicago and Austin, offering the atmosphere of a cocktail bar without alcohol. Breweries have added non-alcoholic beers to their taps and positioned their taprooms as family-friendly community spaces.
These adaptations confirm the argument of Section 4: what the bar offered was not only alcohol but a social form, the gathering place where people could meet without an agenda, the counter at which strangers became regulars, the ritual of the round. If the form can be preserved without the substance, the third place can survive the decline of drinking. The question is economic as much as cultural: bars have depended on the high margins of alcohol, and whether they can sustain themselves on non-alcoholic drinks and activities is uncertain.
The adaptation also changes the identity of the bar. The traditional tavern was defined by drinking; its regulars were drinkers, and the non-drinker was an outsider. The reinvented bar, with its mixed menu, aims to be a space where drinkers and non-drinkers mingle on equal terms. In this sense, it embodies the blurring of the boundary between drinker and non-drinker discussed earlier. The third place of the future may be defined less by what is consumed than by the fact of gathering.
This is the fifth claim of this article: American sociability is relocating from the night to the day and from the bar to the activity. Run clubs, daytime dance parties and other sober rituals seek communitas and collective effervescence through exertion, rhythm and shared experience rather than intoxication. They offer gains in health and safety but may select for the fit and affluent and lack the spontaneity, inclusiveness and licensed intimacy of the drinking place.
7. Conclusion: a sober society?
The United States is not becoming a sober society. Nearly half of adults still drink, and alcohol remains embedded in many of its rituals. But the decline of drinking since 2023, after four decades of stability, marks a significant cultural change. For the first time since Gallup began measuring, a majority of Americans regard moderate drinking as harmful, and nearly half do not drink at all.
The anthropological perspective developed here shows that this change reaches far beyond health and consumption. The decline of drinking removes a culturally licensed time-out, obliging Americans to court, confide and transgress without their customary excuse. It marks a shift from a Dionysian to an Apollonian ethos, carried by a secular, individual and medical temperance. It preserves the form of drinking rituals through non-alcoholic vessels while emptying them of their substance. It opens a politics of the licit intoxicant, illustrated by the brief rise and federal restriction of THC drinks. And it relocates sociability from the bar to the activity, from the night to the day.
These changes raise questions that the coming years will answer. Will the new sober rituals produce communities as strong as those of the tavern, or will the decline of drinking contribute to the fragmentation of social life? Will a new licit intoxicant take alcohol’s place, or will American sociability learn to function without one? Will the Apollonian turn prove durable, or will it give way, as the temperance era did, to a new Dionysian reaction? What is already clear is that a society that drinks less must find other ways to do what drinking did: to mark occasions, to bind groups, to license release and to bring strangers together. The search for those ways is one of the quiet social experiments of the present.
References
Benedict, Ruth. 1934. Patterns of Culture. Boston: Houghton Mifflin.
Courtwright, David T. 2001. Forces of Habit: Drugs and the Making of the Modern World. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
Douglas, Mary, ed. 1987. Constructive Drinking: Perspectives on Drink from Anthropology. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Douglas, Mary. 1966. Purity and Danger: An Analysis of Concepts of Pollution and Taboo. London: Routledge and Kegan Paul.
Durkheim, Émile. 1995 [1912]. The Elementary Forms of Religious Life. New York: Free Press.
Gallup. 2026. Consumption Habits Survey: Alcohol Use. Washington, DC: Gallup.
Goffman, Erving. 1963. Stigma: Notes on the Management of Spoiled Identity. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall.
MacAndrew, Craig and Robert B. Edgerton. 1969. Drunken Comportment: A Social Explanation. Chicago: Aldine.
Mauss, Marcel. 1990 [1925]. The Gift: The Form and Reason for Exchange in Archaic Societies. London: Routledge.
Oldenburg, Ray. 1989. The Great Good Place. New York: Paragon House.
Turner, Victor. 1969. The Ritual Process: Structure and Anti-Structure. Chicago: Aldine.
United States Surgeon General. 2025. Alcohol and Cancer Risk: The U.S. Surgeon General’s Advisory. Washington, DC: Department of Health and Human Services.
Whitaker, Holly. 2019. Quit Like a Woman: The Radical Choice to Not Drink in a Culture Obsessed with Alcohol. New York: Dial Press.
Driss EFFINA, PhD
Independent Researcher, Global Strategy Files
The opening pages of our four country reports: United States, United Kingdom, Japan and China. A free PDF, sent to your inbox.
You will also receive occasional analysis from Global Strategy Files. Unsubscribe in one click, at any time.