Decoded

Ancestors in the Machine: AI Resurrection and the Reinvention of Chinese Ancestor Worship

Decoded analysis cover: Ancestors in the Machine: AI Resurrection and the Reinvention of Chinese Ancestor Worship
Anthropology of Contemporary China | Article 9 of 10

Abstract

Since 2023, Chinese companies have offered to “resurrect” the dead: to build talking, moving avatars of deceased relatives from photographs, videos and voice recordings. Prices range from a few dozen yuan on e-commerce platforms to several thousand for a tablet-based avatar. A Nanjing executive speaks weekly with an avatar of his late mother; a grieving father plays recordings of his son at the grave; a family pays for deepfaked video calls so that a grandmother will not learn that her son has died. In 2024, unauthorised avatars of dead celebrities provoked public protests from their families.

This article argues that AI resurrection in China should be read not as a foreign technology imposed on Chinese mourning but as a new chapter in Chinese ancestor worship. Drawing on Maurice Freedman and Arthur Wolf on ancestors and ghosts, Robert Hertz on death as a process, Sigmund Freud and the “continuing bonds” school of grief research, and the ethnography of spirit mediums, it makes five claims. First, the avatar is a talking tablet: it turns the one-way address of ancestor rites into a dialogue. Second, by preserving the dead as individuals, it suspends the slow depersonalisation by which the dead became ancestors. Third, the human-operated deepfake call is a technological continuation of spirit mediumship. Fourth, in some uses the avatar postpones a death’s social reality, the opposite of mourning. Fifth, disputes over celebrity avatars show that the likeness of the dead is treated as kin property.

Keywords: death, ancestors, mourning, artificial intelligence, kinship, mediumship, China

1. Introduction: “I truly regard it as a mother”

Whenever stress at work builds up, Sun Kai, a co-founder of the Nanjing company Silicon Intelligence, turns to his mother. She died in 2018. What he talks to is an avatar on a tablet, rendered from the shoulders up to look and sound like her. “I do not treat [the avatar] as a kind of digital person,” he told NPR. “I truly regard it as a mother.” He speaks with her at least once a week (NPR via MPR News).

His company is one of several Chinese firms that, since 2023, have offered what the industry calls “resurrection” (复活) or “digital immortality”. Western media have covered the trend as a curiosity of AI or as an ethical warning about “deadbots”. Chinese debate has focused on consent, fraud and whether the practice helps or harms the grieving.

This article asks a different question: what does AI resurrection do to the Chinese dead? Chinese society has one of the world’s most elaborate traditions of relations with the dead, organised around ancestor worship, mortuary ritual and, in some regions, spirit mediums who let the dead speak. A technology that lets the dead speak, look and answer back does not enter an empty space. It enters a crowded one, and it rearranges it.

This is the ninth article in a series on contemporary Chinese social life. The first article examined an app that sought a witness for the solitary dead. This article turns to the opposite problem: not dying unnoticed, but not being allowed to finish dying.

A note on method

The article is interpretive and documentary. It draws on Chinese and international reporting, company statements, legal texts and public debates, read against the anthropology of Chinese death and kinship and the psychology of grief. It does not rest on fieldwork with users. Reporting tends to feature company founders and striking cases, and the number of ordinary users remains uncertain.

2. The phenomenon: a market in digital immortality

Providers and prices

ProviderProductPrice reportedSource
Silicon Intelligence (Nanjing)Basic avatar from under a minute of video and audio; tablet versionsFrom 199 yuan for the basic service; up to several thousand dollars for tablet versionsNPR; The Batch
Super Brain (Jiangsu)Chat avatar in an app or “AI photo frame”; human-operated deepfake video calls10,000 to 20,000 yuan in late 2023, later about 5,000 to 10,000 yuanAFP via eNCA; MIT Technology Review
E-commerce sellersAnimated photographs and simple chat servicesFrom a dozen to a few hundred yuan; one advertised 52.1 yuanBeijing News; The Paper

Super Brain’s founder, Zhang Zewei, said the company had made digital replicas for more than 1,000 clients between March 2023 and spring 2024 (MIT Technology Review). Both major firms say they require authorisation from the person being cloned or, for the deceased, from family members with proof of kinship (NPR via WFDD).

Uses

Reporting describes several distinct uses:

  • Conversation with the dead. Users like Sun Kai speak regularly with an avatar for comfort and advice.
  • Grave-side presence. The bereaved father Seakoo Wu placed his phone on his son’s gravestone and played a recording of him, and hired firms to clone his son’s face and voice (AFP via Briefly).
  • Public tribute. In January 2024, the musician Bao Xiaobai shared an AI-generated video of his daughter, who had died in 2021 at the age of 22, singing and speaking to her family (Beijing News).
  • Concealing a death. A Nanjing man paid for three deepfaked video calls in which a Super Brain employee, wearing his dead uncle’s face and voice, told his grandmother on holidays that he was too busy working in a distant city to come home. “My grandma didn’t suspect anything,” he said (MIT Technology Review).
  • Fan resurrection of celebrities. In March 2024, short-video platforms filled with AI videos of dead stars, including the singer Coco Lee and the actors Godfrey Gao and Qiao Renliang, made without their families’ consent (Yicai).

Seasonality

The market follows the ritual calendar. Xinhua reported that advertisements for AI resurrection multiplied on e-commerce and social platforms around the Qingming festival, the spring festival of tomb-sweeping, and described the practice as a new Qingming “business” (Xinhua). Even a large cemetery company, Fu Shou Yuan, has explored using generative AI in its services (NPR via MPR News). The new technology has slotted into the oldest rhythm of Chinese relations with the dead.

3. The talking tablet: ancestors, ghosts and the avatar

The tablet and the grave

In the classic Chinese system described by Maurice Freedman, the dead were cared for in two places. At the grave, the body rested, and its siting affected the fortunes of descendants. In the house or the lineage hall, the soul resided in a wooden ancestral tablet (神主牌) inscribed with the name of the deceased. Before the tablet, descendants burned incense, offered food and reported important family events. The tablet was not a portrait. It bore a name, not a face. The ancestor was present as a position in a genealogy, not as a personality.

At Qingming, families sweep tombs, burn incense and paper money, and tell the dead what has happened in the past year. As MIT Technology Review observed, these conversations have always been one-way (MIT Technology Review). The dead listened; they did not reply, except through signs, dreams or, in some regions, mediums.

From monologue to dialogue

The AI avatar changes the grammar of this relationship. It adds three things the tablet lacked: a face, a voice and an answer. Super Brain markets one of its products as an “AI photo frame”, a tablet that sits in the home like a portrait and can talk (MIT Technology Review). Physically and ritually, it takes the place of the ancestral tablet and the memorial photograph. Functionally, it transforms the ritual address to the dead from a monologue into a dialogue.

That change is profound. Chinese ancestor rites were organised around speaking to the dead. The avatar offers speaking with them. The dead are no longer only recipients of offerings and reports; they become interlocutors who comfort, advise and joke.

Preventing ancestralisation

The change has a further, less obvious consequence. In the classic system, the dead did not remain individuals forever. Over generations, individual tablets were retired, and remote forebears merged into a collective body of lineage ancestors, honoured together rather than one by one. Robert Hertz described death everywhere as a transformation: the deceased is gradually converted from a lost individual into a member of the collective dead. Chinese ancestor worship was one of the most elaborate versions of this transformation.

The avatar works against it. It preserves the dead precisely as an individual: a particular face, voice, manner of speech, even a particular stock of opinions. Sun Kai deliberately disconnected his mother’s avatar from the internet so that it would not learn of current events (NPR via WFDD): she remains fixed at the moment of her death, unchanged. The avatar freezes the dead at the stage of personality and prevents their passage into the collective.

Arthur Wolf distinguished three kinds of beings in Chinese religion: gods, ghosts and ancestors. The avatar dead fit none of these categories easily. They are not ghosts, since they are cared for by kin. But they are not ancestors in the classic sense either, since they do not dissolve into the lineage. They are a new category: the suspended dead, kept individually present by technology and never allowed to complete the passage that Hertz described.

4. Speaking for the dead: mediums old and new

The medium’s voice

The one-way character of ancestor rites was never absolute. In many parts of southern China, Hong Kong and Taiwan, families consulted spirit mediums who allowed the dead to speak. In Cantonese practice, the ritual known as man mai (问米), “asking the rice”, involved a medium, usually a woman, who entered trance and spoke in the voice of a deceased relative, answering questions about the family, the afterlife and unfinished business. Taiwanese and Hokkien traditions have comparable practices of descending to the underworld to meet the dead. Officially condemned as superstition on the mainland for much of the twentieth century, such practices nonetheless persisted in many places.

The medium solved a specific problem: the desire of the living to hear the dead respond. She did so by lending her body and voice to the deceased, who spoke through her in the first person.

The deepfake call as possession

One of the services offered by Super Brain reproduces this structure almost exactly. In its deepfake video calls, a company employee or a contracted therapist speaks to the bereaved while wearing the face and voice of the dead, generated by AI (MIT Technology Review). A living human performs the dead in the first person, through a technological mask.

This is spirit mediumship in a new medium. The trance has been replaced by software, the medium’s body by a screen, and the ritual fee by a commercial price. But the core structure is the same: a living specialist gives the dead a voice for the comfort of the living. The difference is that the medium claimed to channel the dead, while the employee performs a simulation. Whether that difference matters to the person on the other end of the call is an open question, and perhaps the crucial one.

Keeping a death from happening

The most striking case of this kind is not about mourning at all. The Nanjing family that commissioned deepfaked calls from a dead uncle did so to prevent the grandmother from learning that her son had died; they feared she would not survive the news (MIT Technology Review).

The practice has a Chinese background. Families often conceal grave news from elderly or sick relatives, especially terminal diagnoses, on the view that protecting them from shock is a form of care. Lulu Wang’s 2019 film The Farewell, based on her own family, made this practice internationally known.

Hertz insisted that death is not a biological instant but a social process, which begins when a death becomes known and is ritually acknowledged. The first article of this series examined the fear of a death that goes unwitnessed. Here, technology is used to prevent a death from being witnessed by the person who would mourn it most. The uncle’s death has happened biologically but has been withheld from his mother socially. The avatar does not help mourning. It postpones it, perhaps for ever. In this use, AI resurrection does not continue a bond with the dead; it denies that there are any dead.

5. Continuing bonds or unfinished mourning?

Freud and the work of mourning

In “Mourning and Melancholia” (1917), Sigmund Freud described mourning as work: the slow, painful process by which the bereaved withdraw their emotional attachment from the lost person, memory by memory, until they are free to attach themselves to the living again. Mourning that fails to complete this work becomes melancholia, a pathological clinging to what is lost. For much of the twentieth century, Western grief psychology followed Freud: healthy grieving meant letting go.

The continuing-bonds turn

In the 1990s, a group of researchers led by Dennis Klass, Phyllis Silverman and Steven Nickman challenged this model. In Continuing Bonds (1996), they argued that many bereaved people maintain an ongoing relationship with the dead, talking to them, consulting them, feeling their presence, and that this is often healthy rather than pathological. Klass himself drew on Japanese ancestor rites as an example of a culture in which the dead remain present in everyday life.

From this perspective, Chinese ancestor worship has always been a system of continuing bonds, institutionalised in ritual. The AI avatar fits this tradition far better than it fits the Freudian model. It is not an alien technology imposed on Chinese mourning; it extends a long-established expectation that the dead remain part of the family.

Where the analogy breaks

Yet the avatar differs from traditional continuing bonds in two respects that matter.

First, ritual bonds were structured. Ancestors were addressed at set times, Qingming, festivals, anniversaries, and in set places, the grave and the altar. The avatar is available at any time, on demand, whenever “stress at work builds up”. A bond structured by the ritual calendar becomes a bond structured by the user’s needs.

Second, ritual bonds were transformative. Over time, ritual moved the dead from the status of a recently lost person to that of an ancestor, and the living from acute grief to reverent remembrance. The avatar, as section 3 argued, freezes the dead in their individual form. It offers continuity without transformation.

Chinese users and commentators are aware of the ambivalence. One user who commissioned an avatar of his uncle warned that he would not recommend it for people who might see the avatar and feel the full intensity of grief again (NPR via WFDD). A Chinese commentary summarised the debate: supporters see technology breaking the loneliness of grief, opponents argue that learning to accept a loved one’s departure is a necessary lesson of life (The Paper). In anthropological terms, the question is whether the avatar can be integrated into a ritual structure that allows mourning to move forward, or whether it will produce a population of the suspended dead and of the permanently bereaved.

6. Who owns the dead? Likeness as kin property

The celebrity controversy

In March 2024, AI videos of dead celebrities spread rapidly on Chinese short-video platforms. An AI Coco Lee told fans she hoped they were all living well; an AI Godfrey Gao said he had felt every message and every expression of care; an AI Qiao Renliang greeted his fans (Yicai). Many fans were moved. The families were not.

Qiao Renliang’s father said publicly that he could not accept the videos, found them distressing and wanted them taken down. “They did not ask for our consent,” he said; his niece had come across one and sent it to him, and it was like “reopening a scar” (Yicai). Godfrey Gao’s family took a legal stance, arguing that the unauthorised use of the deceased’s likeness was an infringement of rights (Woshipm).

Fans as fictive kin

The dispute reveals two competing claims to the dead. Fans claimed a relationship of affection: they had loved the star, mourned him, and wanted to hear him again. In a sense, they were acting as fictive kin, performing an ancestor rite for someone who was not their ancestor. Families claimed a relationship of kinship: the dead belonged to them, and only they could decide whether, and how, he might speak again.

In the classic Chinese system, the answer would have been clear. Only descendants could make offerings to an ancestor; offerings by strangers were, if anything, a sign that the dead had become a ghost, a being without kin, fed by the community at large during the Ghost Festival. Read through Arthur Wolf’s categories, fan resurrections treat dead celebrities as public ghosts, while their families insist that they remain private ancestors.

The law follows kinship

Chinese law has sided with kinship. Under the 2022 rules on “deep synthesis” services issued by the Cyberspace Administration and other regulators, providers offering the editing of biometric information such as faces and voices must have users notify the person concerned and obtain their separate consent; commentators argue that, for the deceased, the consent of close relatives responsible for protecting the dead person’s likeness is required (Xinhua). The Civil Code allows close relatives to protect the name and likeness of the deceased. In September 2026, the Supreme People’s Court issued an opinion on AI-related disputes that sets out rules on the use of AI to infringe personality rights, including in cases of “resurrecting” the dead (People’s Daily app).

The legal outcome confirms the anthropological point. The likeness of the dead, their face and voice, is treated as a form of kin property: an inheritance held by close relatives, who alone can authorise its reanimation. The digital dead, like the ancestral tablet, belong to the family.

7. The state and the synthetic person

Official Chinese responses to AI resurrection combine three concerns.

The first is fraud. Deepfaked voices and faces have been used in scams, and both regulators and companies stress the need for authorisation and proof of kinship. The requirement that providers mark generated content, and proposals to add watermarks, are aimed at preventing the misuse of realistic avatars (Xinhua).

The second is personality rights and family feeling. The courts and official media have framed unauthorised resurrections as harms to the dignity of the dead and to the feelings of their families, and the 2026 Supreme Court opinion promised a “prudent and inclusive” approach that would balance rights protection with the development of the AI industry, insisting that inclusiveness did not mean indulgence (People’s Daily app).

The third, less explicit, concern is ritual order. The party-state has long sought to reform funerary customs: promoting cremation, discouraging lavish funerals, and, more recently, encouraging “civilised” and “green” forms of commemoration such as online tomb-sweeping. AI resurrection fits ambiguously into this agenda. It is modern, digital and often promoted as a civilised alternative to burning paper offerings. But it also revives, in a new form, practices that official ideology long treated as superstition, such as speaking with the dead through mediums.

The state’s approach, so far, has been to regulate the technology through the categories of consent, property and fraud, rather than through the categories of religion. It treats the avatar as a synthetic person whose rights belong to the family, not as a ritual object. This may be the most effective way to govern it. It also leaves untouched the deeper anthropological question of what the avatar does to mourning.

8. Comparisons: griefbots, VR reunions and robot funerals

SocietyPracticeDistinctive featureContrast with China
United StatesGriefbots and “legacy” chatbots, such as HereAfter AI, which records interviews with the living; the chatbot app Replika began as a project to recreate a friend who died in 2015Often prepared by the person before death; framed as personal memoryChinese services are more often commissioned by relatives after death, on the model of ancestor care
South KoreaA 2020 television documentary, Meeting You, used virtual reality to stage a reunion between a mother and her dead daughterA one-off, televised ritual of farewellCloser to a structured mourning rite than to an ongoing relationship
JapanBuddhist memorial services for broken robot dogs; experiments with a robot reciting sutras at funeralsTechnology integrated into existing Buddhist ritualChinese avatars largely bypass religious institutions and enter the home directly

The comparison shows that the Chinese case is distinctive less for its technology than for its kinship logic. In the United States, the griefbot is typically an extension of the individual self, a digital legacy authored in life. In China, the avatar is typically an object of kin care, commissioned by descendants and governed by the family’s rights over the dead. The Korean VR reunion, by contrast, was designed as a single farewell, a ritual of separation, while Chinese avatars are designed for continuing presence. And Japan has integrated new technologies into the ritual frame of Buddhist temples, while in China the avatar moves into the home, where ancestors have always lived.

9. Conclusion: the dead who do not finish dying

AI resurrection is often presented as a radical break: a technology that challenges human finitude. Read through the Chinese tradition, it looks more like a mutation of ancestor worship.

  • The avatar is a talking tablet, which turns the one-way address of ancestor rites into a dialogue, and installs a face and voice where the tablet held only a name.
  • By preserving the dead as individuals, it suspends ancestralisation, producing a new category of the suspended dead, neither ghosts nor ancestors.
  • The human-operated deepfake call is a technological mediumship, in which a living specialist gives the dead a first-person voice.
  • In its most extreme use, the avatar postpones a death’s social reality, keeping an elderly mother from learning that her son has died.
  • It fits the continuing-bonds tradition of Chinese mourning but removes the ritual structure that once moved the dead and the living forward.
  • Disputes over celebrity avatars show that the likeness of the dead is kin property, and Chinese law has followed kinship in protecting it.

The first article of this series began with a fear: that one might die without being noticed. This article ends with its mirror image: that one might be noticed, and kept, so insistently that one never finishes dying. Both fears concern the same thing, the passage that Hertz described, by which the dead are taken back by society and given a new place. In the first case, the passage cannot begin because no one is there. In the second, it cannot end because someone will not let go. Between the unwitnessed death and the endless resurrection lies the ritual work that Chinese families have always done, and are now trying to do again with new instruments.

Questions for fieldwork

  • How do users integrate avatars into existing rites: are they used mainly at Qingming and anniversaries, or daily?
  • Do avatars change over time, as users add new data, or are they deliberately frozen?
  • How do older relatives, who grew up with tablets, graves and mediums, respond to avatars of the dead?
  • In families that use avatars, does mourning appear to move forward, stall, or take a new form?
  • What happens to avatars when their creators die: are they inherited, deleted or abandoned?

References

Theoretical and ethnographic works

  • Freedman, Maurice. 1979. The Study of Chinese Society. Ed. G. W. Skinner. Stanford: Stanford University Press.
  • Freud, Sigmund. 1917. “Trauer und Melancholie.” Internationale Zeitschrift für ärztliche Psychoanalyse 4.
  • Hertz, Robert. 1907. “Contribution à une étude sur la représentation collective de la mort.” L’Année sociologique 10.
  • Klass, Dennis, Phyllis R. Silverman and Steven L. Nickman (eds.). 1996. Continuing Bonds: New Understandings of Grief. Washington, DC: Taylor & Francis.
  • Potter, Jack M. 1974. “Cantonese Shamanism.” In A. P. Wolf (ed.), Religion and Ritual in Chinese Society. Stanford: Stanford University Press.
  • Watson, James L., and Evelyn S. Rawski (eds.). 1988. Death Ritual in Late Imperial and Modern China. Berkeley: University of California Press.
  • Wolf, Arthur P. 1974. “Gods, Ghosts, and Ancestors.” In A. P. Wolf (ed.), Religion and Ritual in Chinese Society. Stanford: Stanford University Press.

Film

  • Wang, Lulu (dir.). 2019. The Farewell. United States.

Law and official documents

  • Cyberspace Administration of China et al. 2022. Provisions on the Administration of Deep Synthesis Internet Information Services (互联网信息服务深度合成管理规定).
  • Supreme People’s Court. 2026. Opinions on Hearing Cases Involving Artificial Intelligence Disputes in Accordance with Law, as reported by People’s Daily app (7 Sep 2026).

Press, commentary and data sources

About this series. This article belongs to a ten-part series on the anthropology of contemporary China published by Global Strategy Files. Each study reads a recent social phenomenon through the tools of anthropology: ritual, kinship, exchange, the body and the sacred.

Driss EFFINA, PhD
Independent Researcher, Global Strategy Files

Free preview
The Q4 2026 Global Outlook

The opening pages of our four country reports: United States, United Kingdom, Japan and China. A free PDF, sent to your inbox.

You will also receive occasional analysis from Global Strategy Files. Unsubscribe in one click, at any time.

author-avatar

About Driss Effina

Dr. Driss Effina is a distinguished economist, prolific author, and geopolitical strategist ‎whose work explores the intersections of power, economics, governance, and global ‎transformation. Holder of a PhD in Economic Sciences, an Engineering Degree in ‎Statistics, and a Master's in Capital Markets, he has dedicated more than two ‎decades to advancing economic research, shaping public policy, and producing works ‎of strategic analysis that have reached readers in over 40 countries.‎ As the founder of Global Strategy Files LLC an independent American publishing ‎house headquartered in Albuquerque, New Mexico Dr. Effina has built one of the ‎most ambitious multilingual geopolitical publishing catalogs of the 2020s, with titles in ‎English, French, Spanish, and German spanning topics from the Gulf monarchies and ‎the Kennedy assassination files to the future of the American economy.‎